qa.sh --strict --matrix on the final tree: 7 passed · 0 failed · 0 warn · 0 skipped, MATRIX 10
towns green. New STRICT gate smoke_bible: band law over EVERY bin off the digOffers surface
(80 offers/5 bins), the buy-everything ledger runs on THE GEM'S BIN so the finder-margin leg is
non-vacuous (bin1: 2 gems, grail asking $19 vs keeper $30; ledger closes to the cent — Σask
$333 → Σoffer $135, gems alone +$21, every non-gem strictly negative), scarcity measured
(emptied bin 0/16 on re-open AND across a full reload; 16 pulls in the save) with the ?game=0
negative control re-opening 16/16 (the detector discriminates). sell_routing amended from the
alpha inequality (credited < paid) to the exact formula (credited == min(basis−1, basis//2),
basis = bandLow-or-pricePaid) — the fence moved from the receipt to the band, which is what
charter law #2 always said; it passed on a banded standard item (+$4 on basis $8). _at_bin
grows an idx param (back-compatible). Money shots in docs/shots/v7_beta/ (the guide card + the
crate at the counter). LANE_F_NOTES §32 (incl. the JING5 fresh-checkout trap: gitignored
web/assets/models synced from m3ultra — also un-warned the validator's 15 cross-pack checks).
README manual: the guide/gem/scarcity rows. Remaining beta charter queued in the round doc:
wantlist + rumors · travel costs a day · Esc-in-person · then GodBay.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
R28's gate had no subject and SKIPPED with its reason printed (look.glb was published, verified,
sha1-proven off the depot — and nothing bound it). D bound it in wave 0. The gate is now
permanent, and flags_check is GREEN:
✓ default boot: look.glb BOUND — 6.5s, 64 tracks
✓ the glance REACHES THE GAME — peak 46 of 396 peds glancing · 0 console errors
✓ ?classic=1: look.glb NEVER FETCHED — the zero-fetch-delta covenant holds
✓ ?classic=1: glance inert at the source — 0 of 269 peds, AND the rng stream still draws
That last line is the design, and it is D's cleverness: THE DETERMINISM IS IN THE DRAW, NOT THE
OUTCOME. D takes from a dedicated glanceRng stream always — so the seeded sequence is identical
whether or not a clip exists — and only flips the flag when fleet.lookClip is real. Under
?classic the roll still happens, the flag never sets, nothing is fetched, the covenant stays
byte-identical. A behaviour added without touching a hash.
The gate asserts the clip's ABSENCE under classic, not merely "0 glancing" — because "0
glancing" alone passes on a fleet that failed to load at all. Present-on-default + absent-under-
classic is the pair a broken fleet cannot satisfy.
F'S OWN GATE CRASHED THE SUITE FIRST: the subject check used pg.goto() on a .glb, which starts a
download, aborts the navigation, and took flags_check down before one assertion ran. A gate that
DIES looking for its subject is worse than one that skips — it reports nothing at all and takes
the suite with it. Now it reads the disk. The vacuous-gate law has a sibling: a gate must survive
its own subject being absent.
No tag — wave 0 rides Spike 2's close, gated on John's footage.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
qa.sh --strict --matrix 7 passed / 0 failed / 0 warn. selfcheck ALL GREEN 156,352/156,352 —
UNCHANGED, confirming the brief's prediction that nothing this round moves a golden. MATRIX
GREEN 10 towns x 7 gates.
F'S POSE GATE HAS NO SUBJECT — SKIPPED with the reason printed, per the vacuous-gate law. The
brief asked for "lean/look poses through the scale gate" and "leaning peds in old frames". There
are no new poses in the game:
· `lean` DOES NOT EXIST. E measured instead of trusting the list — the stash's 34 clips have no
lean, and find -iname "*lean*" across ultra returns nothing. Brief and kickoff both called it
already-cached. The premise was half wrong, and E found it the only way these are ever found.
· `look.glb` is shipped, verified, published, sha1-checked by fetching the bytes BACK off the
public depot — AND NOTHING BINDS IT. loadPedFleet() loads walk, idle, sit. No look. E's
handoff said it plainly ("-> D: gate it behind an opt the way rigs.js gates sit"); D's entire
R28 commit is LANE_D_NOTES.md, 48 lines, docs only. The run order said "when E's clips land:
D (#1 wiring)" — the log says D committed BEFORE E shipped.
Nobody was careless; the wave order was. Every check E ran was real and passed, and none of them
could see that no consumer exists. A GATE ON THE ARTIFACT CANNOT SEE THE WIRE — fifth appearance
of the R17 pattern this epoch and the cheapest yet to have missed, because the artifact was
perfect.
v5.1 SHIPS ANYWAY, AND DOES NOT CLAIM THE SPIKE. An unbound clip is inert: nothing is broken,
the game is unchanged and correct. This is not R18's "known breach", it is an unfinished item,
and holding a polish tag over an inert file would be precious. What ships is the sweep:
C's audioEmitter (its own v3.0 note had specified it wrong on both halves — "the panner was
inert"), and TWO backlog items KILLED WITH THE MEASUREMENT — B's awning ripple and D's
instrument LOD, the oldest tri item on the books. They don't leave the backlog "deferred"; they
leave it gone, with the number that killed them.
Filed for R29 (D, one opt): rigs.js gains `look` the way it gates `sit`; F passes it from the
shell. Then the pose gate has a subject and F runs it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
qa.sh --strict --matrix: 7 passed / 0 failed / 0 warn. selfcheck ALL GREEN 156,352/156,352 ·
MATRIX GREEN 10 towns x 7 gates · scaffold_check GREEN (F's re-pins took) · flags harness green,
carrying the kill-the-server gate and the beta crate gate.
F RE-PINNED ITS OWN FILES per A's handoff (A doesn't edit other lanes' files, correctly):
GOLDEN_HASH 0x3fa36874 -> 0x5f76e76 · GIG_GOLDEN 0xb1d48ea1 -> 0xec7a2d39 · melbourne · katoomba
· the captions. AND A CAUGHT A LIVE HAZARD IN F'S GATE: hash_ok carried `or ('3fa36874' in
r.stdout)` — a bare-string OR-clause, dead the moment the covenant moved and worse than dead,
because it would go green off a SENTENCE ABOUT the old covenant appearing in stdout. Deleted.
The check derives from GOLDEN_HASH or it doesn't exist.
JOHN'S RULING IS THE EPOCH'S BEST LINE: the covenant is anti-drift machinery, not a defect
preservative. 0x3fa36874 did its job for five epochs — it never drifted. It just was never right,
and no hash can catch what was wrong in the first commit. A golden proves NOTHING CHANGED; it
cannot prove anything is CORRECT. Every gate we own was green over a world of back walls, and the
only thing that ever saw it was a human standing in the street looking at a wall.
THE FRONTAGE FRAME TOOK FIVE ATTEMPTS, FOUR OF THEM F'S FAULT:
1-3. cluster pose (the town's heart isn't this shop) / lot-anchored facing along the edge /
lot-normal facing — three photographs of empty road. Also never winnable: the shops faced
backwards the whole time. F was posing a camera at a wall and tuning the geometry.
4. B's helper — and F THREW THE RESULT AWAY. poseForShopFront RETURNS a pose; it does not
apply one. F called it, error-checked it, and never touched the camera, so the frame was
the spawn paddock — and F's error-check PASSED, because the call succeeded perfectly. The
vacuous check one last time, in the last frame of the epoch.
5. Applied it -> MONSTER ROBOT PARTY. Sign, door, awning, a ped walking in off Musgrave Road.
The measurement that would have found the facade bug in five minutes — compare the two
conventions against each other — is the one nobody ran for nine rounds, F included, right up to
the vacuous 72/72 F nearly filed as "B is wrong".
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
B's micro-task found it while fixing F's frame, and F's three photographs of empty road are the
evidence: it was never the pose. plan_osm.js:443 aims the lot's -Z at the road ("facade (-Z)
faces road"); buildings.js:404 draws the facade on the local +Z face. Exactly opposite. The
shopfront — sign, door, R26 crate mark — lands on the far side and the street gets a blank wall.
Since R18. v4.0 shipped on it. katoomba_real's street_noon, the bookmark the tours have shot
since R9, is 46 draws of bare road.
Root cause: CITY_SPEC contradicts itself — :71 (lots contract) says -Z, :335 (R15 posters) says
"+Z, B's canon" — and each generator implements one half. Synthetic follows B's canon and looks
right, which is why every golden passes and nobody saw it for nine rounds. The epoch's signature
species and its worst instance: not a gate failing on correct behaviour, but a gate suite GREEN
over a product that is wrong.
F VERIFIED IT AND F'S FIRST CHECK WAS VACUOUS — recorded because it nearly ended the round the
wrong way. F measured each lot's ry against CITY_SPEC:71's own convention and got 35/35 and 72/72
FACING, a clean contradiction of B. But plan_osm IMPLEMENTS :71, so testing :71's data against
:71's rule is self-agreement — it cannot fail. A self-consistent check over a self-contradicting
spec passes under either convention, which is exactly why nine rounds of checks missed this, and
why F nearly filed "B is wrong" with a green number in hand. The only test that sees it compares
the two conventions. F's own frames already had.
Not F's to fix and B was right not to either: A's file, it moves every real-town plan (36 goldens
re-pin under the amendment law), and a self-contradicting spec is Fable's to rule, not a lane's
to pick a side of. B proved the one-liner (ry = atan2(-nx,-nz) → katoomba 0/72 → 72/72, F's money
shot 4m from Musgrave Road) and reverted it — the same discipline F applied to A's sweep and E's
validator, arriving from the other direction.
Order: Fable rules the spec → A lands the line + re-pins the goldens in ONE commit → F re-gates,
re-shoots, tags. Everything else is done and green: the kill-the-server gate, the reader, the
sandbox, the interior money shot (interiors pose themselves; the crate is real either way).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
THE KILL-THE-SERVER GATE, permanent and green (charter law #1 made falsifiable):
ARM 1 server-up · gone[3] → 117 survivors · items[] 120, identity AND ORDER intact ·
COLLATERAL 0 · `gone` carries the atlas id verbatim (R26 fence)
ARM 2 killed mid-session · enter 6ms vs control 6ms (Δ+0) · worst frame 204ms vs control
202ms (Δ+2) · room complete from files · ZERO game errors · EXACTLY 1
refused connection
ARM 3 server-down boot · pure tier 1, gone[0] · ZERO game errors · exactly 1 refusal
SANDBOX · POST/PUT/PATCH/DELETE all 501 · a mint shop 404s
The subject exists only because G built `make-fixture`: production `gone` is EMPTY (0 sales
since 2026-07-01), so this gate would have passed vacuously forever on live data.
CORRECTION 1 — "ZERO console errors on server death" is UNACHIEVABLE, and F measured why. A
fetch to a dead host logs net::ERR_CONNECTION_REFUSED at the BROWSER level; no .catch() sees it.
To log zero the reader would have to know the server is dead WITHOUT ASKING. One refusal is the
irreducible cost of discovering death. F's replacement is strictly stronger: ZERO errors from
game code, and EXACTLY ONE refusal — which PROVES the circuit breaker. Without the breaker it is
one error per shop entry forever, and "zero" could never tell a working breaker from a broken
one because both fail it. F is the beneficiary of this change, so it is filed loudly in §27 for
Fable to ratify or overrule, not quietly relaxed.
CORRECTION 2 — F's frame assertion was weak: `< 250ms` is a number with no control. ARM 2 first
reported worst-frame 201ms and PASSED. But entering a shop rebuilds an interior, which costs the
same with or without a server — so an absolute threshold measures Lane C's room build, not the
network. The arm now walks the same shop with the breaker tripped and asserts the DELTA: 202ms
control, 204ms killed, Δ+2ms. The death cost nothing the room didn't. F told A the same thing one
round ago; a number without a control is not a measurement.
THE TOUR — 3 of 4 frames, and the 4th is FILED NOT SHIPPED. The real crate (the money shot: its
own 120 records, price stickers, the keeper), a mint crate (captioned MINT — plausible, not
real), the classic covenant. 0 page errors. The FRONTAGE frame does not land after three
attempts and F will not ship a frame that doesn't show what its caption claims: the cluster
primitive answers "where is this town's heart", which is not the question a frontage frame asks
— Red Hill's heart is 2 shops/60m and does not contain Monster Robot. Next: ask B, who owns the
frontage and shipped its mark this round. Re-deriving B's anchor in a tour script is how you get
three bad frames.
Also: the interior beauty shot came back with the HUD across it — R21's lesson, fixed on the
street frames only. Now every DOM overlay is hidden, not a guessed selector list.
NOT TAGGED. qa.sh --strict --matrix and the frontage frame remain.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The fence went in and the hold ended. C ruled, and both lanes titled their commit the same
thing: "my rule was the stale thing." E's one line:
SLOT_ID_PREFIX = {"real": "sku_", "mint": "mint_"} # sourcing-scoped, not one space
qa.sh --strict --matrix: 7 passed / 0 failed / 0 warn. selfcheck ALL GREEN 156,212/156,212 ·
MATRIX GREEN 10 towns x 7 gates · flags harness (carrying F's beta gate: 15 crates / 105 pairs /
0 shared titles, sourcing real+mint, ZERO 404s, 0 console errors) · atlas-QA OK, 15 atlases
valid, 15 LICENCE LINES SHOWN — R24's finding #4 at full scale, where one silently printed none.
The ruling is the round's keeper. Fable: prefixes are namespace fences. E's comment makes G's
judgment law: "`sku_` names a POS copy on a shelf, `mint_` names a dealgod listing standing in
for one... a prefix that lies doesn't fail a gate, it SELLS THE WRONG RECORD out of a real shop
to satisfy a minted stand-in. Never treat them as one space (same standing note as plan-ids vs
godverse-ids)."
That closing clause is F's R24 collision — plan id 31 vs godverse id 31, which walked F's own
harness into a cafe — promoted from a finding to a standing law, and re-derived independently by
G in the layer that moves money. The bug F found by entering the wrong shop is the bug G refused
to ship by selling the wrong record.
The rule bent; the id spaces didn't. That is the right direction: a rule describes an intent, and
when a legitimate case fails it, the description is what's wrong — PROVIDED somebody measured
that the intent still holds. F measured it before the ruling (non-positional, seeded, stable,
0 reuse across 15 crates), which is what made the ruling a decision instead of a guess. Holding
the tag was never about the rule being wrong; it was about who gets to say so.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The full qa.sh --strict --matrix run confirms the hold and sizes it. Green: selfcheck ALL GREEN
156,212/156,212 · MATRIX GREEN 10 towns x 7 gates · flags harness (carrying F's beta gate:
distinctness, sourcing, zero 404s, 0 console errors) · consistency · figure-scale.
Red: the manifest validator alone — atlas-QA, 14 identical errors, all 14 mint crates, one
sourcing-blind assertion, one line. The real crate passes.
Recording the ratio because it IS the argument: the beta is finished. What stands between it
and the tag is a rule meeting a case written before the case existed — C's to rule, E's to
land, and not F's to quietly loosen on its own behalf.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
EVERY CRATE IS DIFFERENT, and F measured it rather than taking G's 15/15 on trust — from the
indexes of record, not by entering one lucky shop: 15 keyed crates, 105 pairs, 0 sharing a
title; 0 crates overlap the generic v2 pack; 0 ids reused across crates (G's sku fix holds at
scale — the R24 vacuity dead at the source, not papered over in F's gate). 4 crates in Red Hill
+ 11 in Newtown = the manifest's 15 exactly, and the manifest lists nothing not on disk.
SOURCING, NOT TIER — C was right and the gate follows C. `tier` is the charter's ladder rung and
a mint atlas is ALSO rung 1: still a file, still offline, still deterministic. What differs is
where the stock came from. 15/15 indexes declare sourcing, every one agrees with the manifest,
a mint crate can never report as real, and the gate PRINTS it per room — provenance a human
never reads isn't doing anything (R24's licence lesson, one round on).
THE 404 TOLERANCE IS DELETED, NOT TUNED. R24 probed every keyed shop and ate a 404 per
atlas-less one; F's smoke could only cope by NAMING them, and a tolerance is a confession. F
filed the real fix as a contract ask rather than inventing it; G built the manifest; F now
consumes it — the shell asks for nothing unlisted. Zero 404s because nothing absent gets asked
for, not because the gate stopped looking. AND DELETING IT IMMEDIATELY CAUGHT A LEFTOVER: F had
wired the boot preload but left a second blind probe at the door, 404ing on every
keyed-but-unfetchable shop. While the gate said "8 probes, expected", a ninth was invisible too.
A named exception starts protecting new bugs the moment the real fix exists.
F's beta gate GREEN: distinctness · sourcing (real + mint rooms) · soft fall silent · ZERO 404s ·
0 console errors, no attribution exceptions. Selfcheck ALL GREEN 156,212/156,212.
TAG HELD — atlas-QA FAIL, 14 errors, and it is not the product. E's SLOT_ID_PREFIX = "sku_"
(validate_atlas.py:73) applies to every pack; E reads `sourcing` at :178 but the slot-id check is
sourcing-blind. All 14 mint crates fail; the real crate passes. A mint crate HAS no POS sku — it
was never in that shop's till — so the rule demands what cannot exist, the same shape as R24's
sweep demanding a cafe carry a godverseShopId.
F measured the rule's intent and it holds: mint_<dealgod listing id>, non-positional, sorted by
it, seeded bake, 0 ids reused across all 15 crates. Only the literal prefix fails. And G refused
to go green the easy way for the best reason — F's own R24 collision grown up: a POS sku and a
dealgod listing id are different id spaces, and filing one under `sku_` recreates that bug
INSIDE the economy, where tier-2's sold-means-gone looks up POS skus. R24's collision entered
the wrong shop; the same collision in the money layer sells the wrong record.
F did not fix E's one line: E's file, C's contract, C's call as its author (the principle Fable
ratified when C overruled `tier`) — and F is the party that benefits, since that line is the
only thing between F and the tag. Cost of waiting: one line. Cost of F being quietly wrong: a
gate that green-lights id-space collisions in the layer that moves money.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
You can boot redhill_godverse, walk down Musgrave Road into Monster Robot Party, riffle its
own real crate and buy a real record. Proven falsifiably, not by eyeball:
base assets/stock_godverse/3962749/ (its own, not the town-wide)
TITLES 120/120 the shop's atlas · 0/120 the generic pack
TEXTURES 2 from stock_godverse/3962749/*.webp · 0 generic — the pixels' own file
BUY rec_0000 "Abstract Latin Lounge II (Part II)" @ $15 → cash 191→176, exact
REBOOT 191/0 restored — gone-this-session, back next boot
Ladder: ?noassets → ZERO network requests · keyed-but-atlas-less shop → 404 → parody, live ·
newtown_real → base null, 350 items: the wire is a NO-OP off the godverse path.
flags_check GREEN (0 fails, 0 warns).
#6a THE WIRE: godverseBaseFor(shop), exported and used by BOTH the shell's boot preload and
the room's lookup — C's cache identity is the LITERAL (type, base) pair, so two sides building
that string differently would drop a real shop to parody, a bug indistinguishable from "no
stock" by eye. One function, one string, one key. Gated on stockReal, never the id alone.
#6b THE GATE: smoke_real_crate + DBG.stockInfo() — permanent, and it cannot pass without
touching its subject (SKIPs with a printed reason when the town/atlas is absent).
FINDING — THE BRIEF'S OWN HONEST-GATE SPEC WAS VACUOUS. It specified id equality. Both packs
number items POSITIONALLY (rec_0000…), so all 120 atlas ids are generic-pack ids too: an
id-equality gate goes GREEN on the generic pack — the exact failure the vacuous-gate law was
written to stop, reproduced inside its first application. Ids there are slot numbers, not
identity. Titles (0 overlap) and the texture URL discriminate; F asserts on those.
FINDING — THE ID SPACES COLLIDE, and it bit F's own selector inside the anti-vacuous gate.
Plan ids (1..N) and godverse ids (31, 767, 3962749) share a numeric space: Silky Oak's godverse
id is 31 and another shop's PLAN id is 31, so enterShop(31) silently entered "Wholefood Cafe"
and the soft-fall assertion PASSED ON AN UNKEYED CAFE. Fixed both ends: 'g:<n>' selects a
godverse id explicitly, a bare number stays the plan id and now REPORTS the collision, and the
smoke asserts it landed in the shop it asked for before asserting anything about it.
FINDING — F'S OWN GATE CRIED THE LOUDEST WOLF WE OWN. classic_regression reported "plan
fingerprint != golden 0x3fa36874 — determinism/prime-law broken" while the covenant was
provably intact. F wrote it in R16 as `hash_ok and returncode == 0` — two assertions, ONE
verdict, reported with the fingerprint's message — so any unrelated selfcheck red screamed that
the byte-identical-forever covenant had broken. Two assertions, two verdicts now. It isn't
enough to fail for a reason; you have to fail for YOUR reason.
FINDING — fail-soft-by-404 vs the 0-console-errors law. The boot preload must resolve a keyed
shop's pack before the door opens (getStockPack is sync), so it probes blind: 9 of Red Hill's
10 keyed shops have no atlas → 404 → parody. That IS fail-soft working, and it is also 8
console errors no .catch() can suppress. Fix is not to loosen the law but to stop probing for
what isn't there: an atlas index in G's namespace (or hasStock on the cache entry, A+G). Filed
as a contract ask, not invented. Until then the smoke counts and NAMES the probes and fails on
any other error — tolerance stated out loud.
Verified the lift is clean: cache 10 keyed → plan 9 keyed, every one a real secondhand shop.
No cafe keyed, zero duplicate ids — there is no mis-stocking.
F did NOT touch A's identity sweep or E's validator. F was the party that would benefit, and
changing a red gate to green in another lane's file to unblock F's own tag would retroactively
devalue every green F has ever reported. Filed instead — and R25 has since landed A's
reconciliation and the six pins, which is the right hands doing it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
v5.0-alpha is NOT tagged. #7a is not a gate that failed, it's a gate that cannot be run:
G's 120 real records are in the tree and byte-identically re-bakeable, and nothing in the
game can reach them. R18's law — release rounds don't ship known breaches.
GREEN (everything except the crate): qa.sh --strict --matrix 7 passed / 0 failed / 0 warn ·
MATRIX GREEN 10 towns x 7 gates · selfcheck 152,015/152,015 (was 161,300, E retired
toowoomba) · flags harness green, so ?classic=1 still holds through the merge · tier 0
?noassets zero fetches + zero console errors (the offline law holds) · tier 1 (v2
town-wide) resolves. Tier 1 (v5, per-shop) is NEVER FETCHED.
FINDING 1 — the atlas contract contradicts itself. LANE_C_PUB:271 publishes
stock_shop_<id>_index.json; C's own loader (stockpack.js:25) fetches
${base}stock_${type}_index.json. Incompatible. G built runtime-compatible (which is why
C's base-override check passed); E built contract-compatible (which is why E's validator
can't see it). Nobody was wrong — the contract was. F recommends amending to G's shape:
it's the only one the runtime can load, and it costs G nothing.
FINDING 2 — the gate built to catch that was blind and green. validate_atlas.py globs a
filename that can't exist at runtime, finds nothing, and returns 0 ("No atlases yet =>
clean pass"), which validate_manifest.py:158 propagates. It conflates "no atlases exist"
with "no atlases matched my glob" — the first is a clean pass, the second is the exact
failure it was written to catch. Pointed at G's index by hand, deeper drift surfaced:
E's line 68 reads provenance top-level while E's own docstring says nested (where G put
it), licence vs license, and a ceiling stale by one round.
FINDING 3 — #7a would have passed vacuously. Walked into The Vintage Record (real shop,
real road) via DBG.enterShop: the crates filled with real covers — from E's 350-item
town-wide v2 pack, not the crate. Zero requests to stock_godverse/, ever. Eyeballed as
written, the gate goes green and proves nothing. Two vacuous gates in one round, same
species: both test the presence of a thing rather than the identity of it.
R24 — three gaps, none F-only: A+G land a godverse_id (verified live: every godverse shop
reports null; the schema has no such field) -> E builds redhill_real (one Overpass fetch,
E's file, outward-facing — not F's to invent) -> C keys the pack cache by type+base
(today a hit returns before base is read, so two stocked shops collide and fail-soft
breaks) -> F passes the per-shop base and re-gates. F deliberately did not build its half:
untestable with no street and no identity field. Filed, not guessed.
Also: A's spacing warn earned on day one — ballarat now warns at 255 m, so the thin tail
has a second member. The README v5 teaser is held with the tag; they're one claim.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The blocking gate is CLOSED, and the epoch closes green.
- #1b THE BLOCKING RE-MEASURE: F's R21 re-measure made the tri diet blocking; B diagnosed layer-by-layer,
the driver traced A -> E (A's own commit: "B's numbers say the fix is E's"), E fixed it, F re-measured:
katoomba venue_night 221,935 (+11%) -> 108,365 (-51%); bendigo 201k -> 124,682; fremantle -> 88,397.
Worst 124,682 — the 200k stress edge is closed. The measure-first loop worked end to end.
- #3 DBG.enterShop(selector) (Lane G's ask): id · registry type · exact name · name substring, resolved
most-specific-first so an id-shaped string can't be shadowed. One-liner QA on any of 23 towns.
- #4 The release tour -> docs/shots/release_v4/: the Fremantle hero · the Fitzroy mecca · the Toowoomba thin
tail · the synthetic control · the ?classic=1 covenant. Every real-town frame poses through F's R21
cluster primitive; B's R22 bookmarks anchor on the same retail heart, so tour and bookmarks agree by
construction. HUD hidden throughout (F's R21 ruling corollary).
The primitive earned itself twice: the first cut posed via street_noon and the MECCA CAME OUT AS BARE
BITUMEN — the same trap as R21. Re-posed through the cluster, Fitzroy reads.
- HONEST FINDING (filed v4.x): the brief asked for the thin tail as "proof the floor holds". It does not,
and the frame says so — Toowoomba reads as an empty road. The floor is a RATIO, not a count: 0.008
shops/edge vs the heroes' 0.06-0.08. Shipped labelled honestly rather than swapped for a flattering town.
- #6 Docs: README v4 section (the towns ARE the product), LANE_F_NOTES §22, F-progress.
qa.sh --strict --matrix GREEN 7/7; MATRIX GREEN — 10 towns × 7 gates (the budget gate green everywhere for
the first time); selfcheck 161,300/161,300 (A's 36 goldens + the 23-town pack).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
All five lanes in (A's venue cluster bias, B's selector-from-index, C's density door-soak, D's relocation
verify PASSES, E's 22-town pack non-gating); F gated and tagged.
- town_matrix.py: a `tram` dimension — B's R20 shop-adjacency ruling verified EXACTLY (newtown runs 16 stops
after B's phantom-stop fix, castlemaine 10; katoomba/fremantle/bendigo FENCED at 3/2/1 shops fronted, all
below the 5-shop floor). 10 towns x 7 gates: boot/determ/district/roads/tram/noassets green on all ten.
- index.html: expose window.PROCITY.tram — B built `routeInfo` FOR F's smoke but nothing published it; F owns
the shell, so F wired the seam.
- RECORDED (ledger #6b — the instruction was "record the new number"): the venue_night re-measure. A's cap
WORKED (posters 438->111) but E's density widening ate it — katoomba 200,965 (+965, R19) -> 221,935
(+21,935, +11%); bendigo 201k (+0.5%); fremantle/newtown/castlemaine in budget. Draws fine everywhere
(151/300 — half budget); tris-only, at the worst night stress view. Filed as R22's first item, where the
tri-diet backlog (instrument LOD, tram tri diet) already lives. katoomba is the outlier: 966 edges, 72 shops.
- Ruling (ledger #6d): the town selector stays ALWAYS-IN-HUD, not ?dbg-gated — THE REAL MAP's product IS the
towns. Corollary (F's own gap): money shots hide the HUD; the R19 alpha shot had the selector in-frame
because F's harness screenshotted the full viewport.
- Beta money shot: Fremantle's real street at golden hour — a corridor of shopfronts, footpaths, a crossing,
gum trees, and a genuinely busy crowd (the density widening, visible). 126d/167k tris, HUD hidden.
- docs: LANE_F_NOTES §20 (the honest why-R20-had-no-tag record) + §21, README beta paragraph, F-progress.
qa.sh --strict GREEN; selfcheck 154141/154141 (A's re-pinned goldens hold).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A resolved the R18 findings (fragmentation cull/join, poster clamp, goldens pinned) + D verified; F gated.
- town_matrix.py: a `roads` dimension — a schema-v2 cache (roads[]) must build the REAL street graph
(norm.mode==='roads', read via the plan_osm opts.report sink); synthetic/fixtures stay marched/synthetic.
10 towns x 6 gates: real roads green everywhere; classic/default proven untouched (roads ride the cache
schema, not a flag — 0x3fa36874 frozen).
- docs/shots/v4_alpha/katoomba_mainstreet.png: the first real-street money shot — Katoomba's actual main
street (asphalt + lane markings, footpaths, a pedestrian crossing, a walking crowd, gig posters, B's town
selector in-frame), PROCITY's look on real bones, 121k tris midday.
- docs: LANE_F_NOTES §18 (why F correctly HELD in R18 — the gate would have failed by design) + §19 (the
close), README real-roads note, F-progress.
qa.sh --strict --soak GREEN 7/7. One filed NON-blocking finding: katoomba_real venue_night 200,965 tris
(+965 / 0.5% over the soft ceiling, poster-count-scales-with-real-edges driven; midday play is 121k) — a
v4.0-beta hardening item (A caps posters per real town), on the opt-in --matrix warn-gate, not a play view.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
F wired the last mile of the real-map scout and gated the whole matrix.
- index.js barrel re-exports registerTownCache/validateTownCache; the shell fetches + registers
assets/towns/<key>.json before generatePlanFor when the town isn't a checked-in fixture — so
?plansrc=osm&town=bendigo_real boots a REAL AU town in the engine (the gap: E's caches were on disk +
in the node selfcheck, but the shell never loaded them → silent Melbourne fallback). Fail-soft
(404 / invalid / ?noassets -> fixture fallback); opt-in, never on the default or ?classic path.
- tools/qa/town_matrix.py (opt-in qa.sh --matrix): boot / determinism / budget / district / ?noassets
across 10 towns (2 synthetic hero seeds + 3 osm fixtures + E's 5 real AU caches). ALL 5x10 GREEN —
Castlemaine at the 6-shop floor still lands a 3-venue district. The existing CityPlan contract eats real
Australian geography: the evidence John charters v4 = THE REAL MAP on.
- docs: LANE_F_NOTES §17 (the town x gate table), README real-town row, F-progress R17.
qa.sh --strict --soak GREEN 7/7. Verified: ?plansrc=osm&town=bendigo_real -> Bendigo, 9 shops, 3 venues, 0 errors.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The closing half of F's bookend. All gates green on the flipped tree (qa.sh --strict --soak: classic
regression + default-boot gate + smokes + no-giants incl. the seated drummer + the full-week soak).
- tour_shots.py -> docs/shots/release_v3_1/: the money shots on the DEFAULT boot (no per-shot flag juggling
now the flip covers it) + a ?classic=1 before/after ("the town before v3"). 7 shots, settled, 0 page errors.
- week_soak.py: re-pointed to the default boot; the leak check now treats an at/below-baseline OR non-climbing
trail as leak-free (a decreasing tex trail is GC/atlas-settle, not a leak — it was false-failing at warn-level).
- docs: README v3.1 flags table (defaults on + ?classic=1), CITY_SPEC v3.1 amendment (the rewritten prime
law + classic covenant, A's deferred edit), LANE_F_NOTES §16, F-progress R16.
Numbers (seed 20261990): default @ venue block 124 draws / 57k tris (<=300/200k); ?classic 161 draws / 24k
tris (the v2 baseline); seated drummer 1.32 m stature; week soak 42 cycles leak-free (net +0/-6).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- README: a v3.0 'venues & gigs, THE DISTRICT' section — what shipped, the flags table, the release tour
- LANE_F_NOTES §14 (R14: F never ran, brief carried) + §15 (the R15 release-close runbook, numbers, gotcha ledger)
- F-progress: R15 release-close summary at the top
- confirmed all five freezes committed (A a3911a4/35da83c, B eee60e0/a0b5784, C 62e38c5/2446ae3, D 9a65f51/66aec0f, E 55f6698)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Wires A–E + D's district together and fires it. Seed 20261990 → "Boolarra Heads": 3 venues, 2 playing
tonight (The Exchange Hotel pub gig-pubrock + an RSL gig-covers, one dark), Screaming Utes $10 on the door.
- gig_state.js → PER-VENUE latches off the shared procity:segment spine (one per venueShopId); all three
hard-won R12 laws kept. New runtime surface window.PROCITY.gigs.byVenue + onOf/openOf/gigOf/coverOf/
bandNameOf/paidOf(id) + markPaidOf/venueShopIds; the R12 single-venue alias kept for one round.
- interior_mode.js: crowd-walla rides the interior tone layer under the live band bed while `on`; an
applause sting fires once on the on->done edge. DELETE the GIG_BED bridge — debt #1, and it was a LIVE
BUG: E renamed pubrock-live->gig-pubrock, so the bridge (gig-pubrock->pubrock-live) pointed at a dead
key => the band would have mimed in silence. room.audio.gigKey (already the manifest key) feeds directly.
- index.html: per-venue cover charge (a night at two venues is two covers), concurrent per-venue setGig
surges, and the outdoor VenueQueue lifecycle (D shipped the class + left the street-side seam to F:
spawn at doors off B's queueZoneFor, drive each frame, dispose by done), exposed as queueCountOf(id).
- interior_scale_check.py: human-size assert now measures STATURE (crown-foot, platform-independent);
world-crown ceiling-clip assert kept as its own line (debt #6).
- flags_check.py smoke_gigs -> THE DISTRICT: band->4, per-venue loop (every gigKey resolves across 3
genres, crowd <= its own watchPoints, no-giants by stature), street budget at the busiest venue block,
the queue assert; plus the R12 determinism/cover/noassets/flags-off arms.
- CITY_SPEC: pin the window.PROCITY.gigs runtime surface. gig_shot.py -> r13 interior + venue_night shots.
qa.sh --strict GREEN 6/6, 0 warn. Interior 63 draws/35k tris; street @ venue block 121 draws/51k tris;
band+crowd stature 1.61-1.81 m under a 4 m ceiling; flags-off fingerprint 0x3fa36874 unchanged.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
F last: five landed lanes → one Friday night. Seed 20261990 → The Thornbury Hotel,
tonight SCREAMING UTES, $10 on the door. qa.sh --strict GREEN 6/6.
- gig_state.js (new, F-owned): quiet → doors (DUSK) → on (NIGHT) → done (DAWN) → quiet.
Rides lighting's procity:segment event (a poll only sees the segments it samples, and
missed the night roll entirely); `state` is a getter because B's audio reads it from its
own rAF while the player is inside a shop.
- ?gigs=1 seam: custom_bands.json fetched in the bootstrap (no fetch flag-off or ?noassets)
→ generatePlanFor(seed, src, {gigs:true, customBands}). 7 of John's 10 names fill the week.
- Cover charge on the R8 buy seam, zero new UI: paid debits once with a toast, re-entry the
same night is free, broke → polite knockback, free nights walk straight in.
- interior_mode: opts.gig → C's gigKey; D's GigCrew (band 3 + crowd 8, 3 dancing) at C's
stage/watch points; both disposed with the room (leak-free over 4 cycles).
- Cross-lane fix at the glue: C emits gigKey 'gig-pubrock', E shipped the bed as
'pubrock-live' — unresolved the pub plays to a silent room and nothing errors. Bridged
here; C/E/Fable owe CITY_SPEC a contract line. Details + 2 more findings in LANE_F_NOTES §12.
- smoke_gigs (16 gates): schedule determinism, band==3, crowd ≤ watchPoints, dance mix, bed
resolves, ≤350 draws (47 rig / 171 placeholder), no-giants by STATURE (the band stands on a
0.32m deck, so world-crown fails a correct band), cover ruling, ?noassets+?gigs.
Flags-off regression gains a v3 arm: no state machine, no plan.gigs, no pub, no venue geo.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
- ROUND3/ROUND4_INSTRUCTIONS.md: 'SUPERSEDED by R5' banner (F4 archive task).
- LANE_F_NOTES §10: round-5 tracking — v2 flag-seam table (?plansrc/?winmap/?dig/?roster,
all pending owning-lane specs), v2 QA-harness plan, v1.1 watch.
- F-progress: round-5 section. Confirmed fal already un-parked at 039c179 (no F change needed).
- v1.1 tag is on watch for Lane C re-map (C1) + Lane E hero-prop bake (E1).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Gate table (LANE_F_NOTES §4) rewritten to R4 all-green with measured evidence:
1 determinism (selfcheck 1301/1301, fingerprint 0x3fa36874) · 2 soak (37 chunks/20 shops,
heap 38->38MB, 0 errors, leak-free) · 3 budget (draws 138/tris 31k, decimated peds) ·
4 asset-free (heap 13->13MB, 0 net) · 5 selfchecks (qa.sh --strict 4/4, 23 GLBs on depot) ·
6 shots (10 full-frame 1280x720, no letterbox, night closed-facade + real interiors).
shots.py: interior tour shots (record/opshop) now capture via DBG.enterShop(id) directly —
they were passing {type} to enterShop (needs id) then calling shot() (which forces street
mode), so both showed streets. Now they show the themed interiors with keeper + hero props.
Verified by a 6-auditor adversarial v1-readiness workflow -> GO.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
interior_mode.js bridges Lane B's enterShop seam to Lane C buildInterior and Lane D
keepers (spawn at counter keeperStand, greet, leak-free over 5 cycles). CitizenSim
wired into the street loop (pop 140, ~96 active midday, worst ~191 draws). tools/:
qa.sh gate runner (all 4 landed gates GREEN --strict), scaffold/consistency checks,
shots.py + soak.py browser harnesses. docs/shots/ reference tree, LANE_F_NOTES
runbook, V2_IDEAS parking lot.
(F's inline seam edits to index.html/skins.js landed with the Lane B commit.)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
