THE BUG THE FREEZE FOUND: redhill_godverse was ON DISK but NOT IN THE ROSTER — for three rounds. The v5
provenance table needed real numbers, so I measured instead of carrying the v4 row forward. The count
didn't match: 23 caches on disk, 22 rostered. The missing one was redhill_godverse — THE TOWN THE ENTIRE
v5 EPOCH WALKS TO.
Mine, squarely. index.json is Lane E's file (write_index()). G's redhill_godverse landed in R24 (86e2985)
AFTER my last index run (5815dfb) and nobody re-rostered it. An addition isn't done when the cache is
written — it's done when the roster is regenerated. That is the exact mirror of my own R24 lesson ("a
retirement isn't done when the cache is deleted; it's done when the consumers are swept"): I wrote the
lesson for deletions and missed its reflection for additions.
WHY FOUR GREEN ROUNDS NEVER CAUGHT IT — a gate-shape lesson. Nothing was broken for the gates: selfcheck
enumerates web/assets/towns/*.json DIRECTLY (so it saw the town; A even pinned its goldens) and F's crate
smoke boots BY KEY (?town=redhill_godverse). The roster's only consumer is B's HUD selector (hud.js, my
R20 ledger #2 design). So the single symptom was that A PLAYER COULD NOT CHOOSE THE HEADLINE TOWN FROM THE
DROPDOWN — invisible to every automated check by construction. A gate that reads around the artifact under
test cannot test it: the vacuous-gate species, one layer out.
Fixed: re-ran write_index() -> 23 rostered, 23 on disk, 0 missing. Only index.json moved (every cache
byte-identical again). selfcheck ALL GREEN 156,212, golden 0x3fa36874 untouched. qa.sh --strict --matrix
7 passed / 0 failed / 0 warn.
-> F (#5, the tour): the money shot walks Musgrave Road into Monster Robot Party. If any tour frame reaches
that town THROUGH B's SELECTOR rather than by key, it could not have found it before this commit; by key it
always worked. Worth one glance at your framing path.
-> B: the dropdown now carries both godverse towns. Your `${t.state ? ', ' + t.state : ''}` handles their
empty state gracefully — nothing needed, and the defensive write is why this cost nothing cosmetically.
-> G: your godverse caches carry no `state`, so they roster as state:''. Harmless (B degrades cleanly). For
"Red Hill, QLD" in the picker, emit `state` — write_index() already prefers the cache's own field.
PROVENANCE v5-FINAL. The ⟨v5.0-FINAL⟩ rows are measured, not inherited — the town-pack row still claimed
v4's "22 towns / 1192 shops", stale since my R24 ballarat retirement and redhill build (now 21 real / 1196
shops / 299 heroes, + both godverse towns = 23 rostered). Added the two v5 art rows: the real-stock atlas
(1 crate, 120 items, Monster Robot's own POS, sku_ ids) and the mint atlases (14 crates, 224 items, seeded
from real dealgod listings, mint_ ids). These are the table's FIRST AMBER ROWS — everything before v5 was
green web-ok; real product photography is the first asset class this project ships that a human must clear
before public release.
I VERIFIED MY OWN PROSE AND IT CAUGHT ME: I first wrote the mint crates as "6 record · 6 book · 3 toy" —
that is the breakdown of all FIFTEEN crates, which includes Monster Robot's REAL record crate. The 14 mint
crates are 5 record · 6 book · 3 toy. A count attributed to the wrong population, one line from being
frozen into the release record. Every other claim in the table re-measured true (21/1196/299/8 states/23
rostered/roster==disk/72/37/120 items/224 items/both zones in-house-green).
THE LICENCE LINE'S STORY, recorded as a mechanism. The amber rows are guarded by exactly one printed line,
so the freeze says why it took two rounds to make honest: R23's glob matched 0 files and returned 0; R25's
permissive `or` fallback let the print go silent while the check still passed — the flag stopped reaching a
human on real product photos while the gate said OK. Now: one spelling, one lookup with one owner, and the
line is COUNTED (judged N => N lines, or FAIL). Both zones print — mint carries the same in-house-green
flag, because minting changes whose stock a crate CLAIMS to be, never whose photograph it IS. Frozen today
at: atlas-QA OK — 15 per-shop atlas(es) valid, 15 licence line(s) shown, 0 warning(s).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
bee7563a76