Lane E R27 (v5.0): provenance v5-final — and the roster gap the freeze caught (ledger #6)
THE BUG THE FREEZE FOUND: redhill_godverse was ON DISK but NOT IN THE ROSTER — for three rounds. The v5 provenance table needed real numbers, so I measured instead of carrying the v4 row forward. The count didn't match: 23 caches on disk, 22 rostered. The missing one was redhill_godverse — THE TOWN THE ENTIRE v5 EPOCH WALKS TO. Mine, squarely. index.json is Lane E's file (write_index()). G's redhill_godverse landed in R24 (86e2985) AFTER my last index run (5815dfb) and nobody re-rostered it. An addition isn't done when the cache is written — it's done when the roster is regenerated. That is the exact mirror of my own R24 lesson ("a retirement isn't done when the cache is deleted; it's done when the consumers are swept"): I wrote the lesson for deletions and missed its reflection for additions. WHY FOUR GREEN ROUNDS NEVER CAUGHT IT — a gate-shape lesson. Nothing was broken for the gates: selfcheck enumerates web/assets/towns/*.json DIRECTLY (so it saw the town; A even pinned its goldens) and F's crate smoke boots BY KEY (?town=redhill_godverse). The roster's only consumer is B's HUD selector (hud.js, my R20 ledger #2 design). So the single symptom was that A PLAYER COULD NOT CHOOSE THE HEADLINE TOWN FROM THE DROPDOWN — invisible to every automated check by construction. A gate that reads around the artifact under test cannot test it: the vacuous-gate species, one layer out. Fixed: re-ran write_index() -> 23 rostered, 23 on disk, 0 missing. Only index.json moved (every cache byte-identical again). selfcheck ALL GREEN 156,212, golden 0x3fa36874 untouched. qa.sh --strict --matrix 7 passed / 0 failed / 0 warn. -> F (#5, the tour): the money shot walks Musgrave Road into Monster Robot Party. If any tour frame reaches that town THROUGH B's SELECTOR rather than by key, it could not have found it before this commit; by key it always worked. Worth one glance at your framing path. -> B: the dropdown now carries both godverse towns. Your `${t.state ? ', ' + t.state : ''}` handles their empty state gracefully — nothing needed, and the defensive write is why this cost nothing cosmetically. -> G: your godverse caches carry no `state`, so they roster as state:''. Harmless (B degrades cleanly). For "Red Hill, QLD" in the picker, emit `state` — write_index() already prefers the cache's own field. PROVENANCE v5-FINAL. The ⟨v5.0-FINAL⟩ rows are measured, not inherited — the town-pack row still claimed v4's "22 towns / 1192 shops", stale since my R24 ballarat retirement and redhill build (now 21 real / 1196 shops / 299 heroes, + both godverse towns = 23 rostered). Added the two v5 art rows: the real-stock atlas (1 crate, 120 items, Monster Robot's own POS, sku_ ids) and the mint atlases (14 crates, 224 items, seeded from real dealgod listings, mint_ ids). These are the table's FIRST AMBER ROWS — everything before v5 was green web-ok; real product photography is the first asset class this project ships that a human must clear before public release. I VERIFIED MY OWN PROSE AND IT CAUGHT ME: I first wrote the mint crates as "6 record · 6 book · 3 toy" — that is the breakdown of all FIFTEEN crates, which includes Monster Robot's REAL record crate. The 14 mint crates are 5 record · 6 book · 3 toy. A count attributed to the wrong population, one line from being frozen into the release record. Every other claim in the table re-measured true (21/1196/299/8 states/23 rostered/roster==disk/72/37/120 items/224 items/both zones in-house-green). THE LICENCE LINE'S STORY, recorded as a mechanism. The amber rows are guarded by exactly one printed line, so the freeze says why it took two rounds to make honest: R23's glob matched 0 files and returned 0; R25's permissive `or` fallback let the print go silent while the check still passed — the flag stopped reaching a human on real product photos while the gate said OK. Now: one spelling, one lookup with one owner, and the line is COUNTED (judged N => N lines, or FAIL). Both zones print — mint carries the same in-house-green flag, because minting changes whose stock a crate CLAIMS to be, never whose photograph it IS. Frozen today at: atlas-QA OK — 15 per-shop atlas(es) valid, 15 licence line(s) shown, 0 warning(s). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
m3ultra
parent
cedc5872fb
commit
bee7563a76
@ -1,5 +1,53 @@
|
||||
# LANE E — cross-lane notes
|
||||
|
||||
## Round 27 — provenance v5-final, and the roster gap the docs freeze caught ⟨v5.0⟩
|
||||
|
||||
**1. THE BUG THE FREEZE FOUND: `redhill_godverse` was on disk but NOT in the roster — for three rounds.**
|
||||
The v5 provenance table needed real numbers, so I measured instead of carrying the v4 row forward. The
|
||||
count didn't match: **23 caches on disk, 22 rostered.** The missing one was **`redhill_godverse` — the
|
||||
town the entire v5 epoch walks to.**
|
||||
|
||||
**Mine, squarely.** `index.json` is Lane E's file (`write_index()`). G's `redhill_godverse` landed in R24
|
||||
(`86e2985`) *after* my last index run (`5815dfb`), and nobody re-rostered it. **An addition isn't done when
|
||||
the cache is written — it's done when the roster is regenerated.** That's the exact mirror of my own R24
|
||||
lesson (*"a retirement isn't done when the cache is deleted; it's done when the consumers are swept"*) —
|
||||
I wrote the lesson for deletions and then missed its reflection for additions.
|
||||
|
||||
**Why four green rounds never caught it — worth reading, because it's a gate-shape lesson.** Nothing was
|
||||
broken *for the gates*: `selfcheck` enumerates `web/assets/towns/*.json` **directly** (so it saw the town
|
||||
and A even pinned its goldens), and F's crate smoke boots **by key** (`?town=redhill_godverse`). The
|
||||
roster's *only* consumer is **B's HUD selector** (`hud.js`, my R20 ledger #2 design). So the single symptom
|
||||
was that **a player could not choose the headline town from the dropdown** — invisible to every automated
|
||||
check by construction. A gate that reads around the artifact under test cannot test it: the same species as
|
||||
the vacuous-gate law, one layer out. **Fixed:** re-ran `write_index()` → **23 rostered, 23 on disk, 0
|
||||
missing**; only `index.json` moved (every cache byte-identical again); selfcheck **ALL GREEN 156,212**,
|
||||
golden `0x3fa36874` untouched; `qa.sh --strict --matrix` **7/0/0**.
|
||||
|
||||
**→ F: this matters for #5, the tour.** The money shot walks Musgrave Road into Monster Robot Party. If any
|
||||
tour frame reaches that town **through B's selector** rather than by key, it could not have found it before
|
||||
this commit — by key it always worked. Worth one glance at your framing path.
|
||||
**→ B:** the dropdown now carries both godverse towns. Your `${t.state ? ', ' + t.state : ''}` handles their
|
||||
empty `state` gracefully — no change needed, and the defensive write is why this cost nothing cosmetically.
|
||||
**→ G:** your godverse caches carry no `state`, so they roster as `state:''`. Harmless today (B degrades
|
||||
cleanly). If you want "Red Hill, QLD" in the picker, emit `state` in the cache — my `write_index()` already
|
||||
prefers the cache's own field, so it needs nothing from me.
|
||||
|
||||
**2. Provenance v5-final (ledger #6).** The ⟨v5.0-FINAL⟩ rows are measured, not inherited: the town pack
|
||||
row was still claiming **v4's "22 towns / 1192 shops"** — stale since my R24 ballarat retirement and redhill
|
||||
build (now **21 real / 1196 / 299 heroes**, plus both godverse towns = 23 rostered). Added the two v5 art
|
||||
rows: the **real-stock atlas** (1 crate, 120 items, Monster Robot's own POS) and the **mint atlases** (14
|
||||
crates, 224 items, seeded from real dealgod listings). **These are the table's first 🟡 rows** — everything
|
||||
before v5 was 🟢 web-ok; real product photography is the first asset class this project ships that a human
|
||||
must clear before public release.
|
||||
|
||||
**3. The licence line's story, written down as a mechanism (ledger #6).** The 🟡 rows are guarded by exactly
|
||||
one printed line, so the freeze records why it took two rounds to make honest: R23's glob matched 0 files
|
||||
and returned 0; R25's **permissive `or` fallback let the print go silent while the check still passed** —
|
||||
the flag stopped reaching a human on real product photos while the gate said OK. Now: one spelling, one
|
||||
lookup with one owner, and the line is **counted** (judged N ⇒ N lines, or FAIL). **Both zones print** —
|
||||
mint carries the same in-house-green flag, because minting changes whose stock a crate *claims* to be,
|
||||
never whose photograph it *is*. Frozen today at **15 crates, 15 flags, every one in front of a human.**
|
||||
|
||||
## Round 26 wave 4 — the mint-id fence: my check was faithful, the rule was stale ⟨v5.0-beta⟩
|
||||
|
||||
**The red was mine and the fix is C's ruling.** My R25 slot-id check demanded `sku_` on every real-stock
|
||||
@ -702,12 +750,50 @@ loader wiring (`spawnRig`/fleet). Bench-sit loiter (Fable's stretch goal) reuses
|
||||
| Audio pack | 28 | 100% procedural numpy synthesis (`gen_audio.py`) | oscillator/noise render → ffmpeg OGG+M4A | 🟢 CC0-equiv, parody-safe |
|
||||
| Stock packs | 3 (350/311/273) | GODVERSE `dealgod` Postgres — **real** cover art | `build_stock_pack.py`: parody-transform metadata + atlas | 🟢 real-art / parody-metadata |
|
||||
| Ped clip **⟨v3.1⟩** | `sit.glb` (E R16; + pre-existing `walk`/`idle` from D/90sDJsim) | Adobe **Mixamo** `Sitting_Idle.fbx` | `fbx_to_clip.py` (Blender, mesh-strip) | 🟢 Mixamo royalty-free (motion only, mesh stripped) |
|
||||
| Town pack **⟨v4.0-FINAL⟩** | **22 real AU towns, all 8 states/territories** — 1192 shops + real street geometry (`roads[]`) | **OpenStreetMap** via Overpass API — bounded per-town bbox; raw shops+roads snapshots committed in `_raw/` | `build_towns.py`: fetch → dedupe/suburb-fill/parody → C's §6 class map → 3× texture cap (drops counted) → v2 cache + roads | 🟢 **ODbL 1.0** (© OSM contributors; `web/assets/towns/SOURCES.md` + `license`/`attribution` on every cache) |
|
||||
| Godverse town *(Lane G's, listed for completeness)* | `newtown_godverse` — 18 shops, rostered in E's `index.json` | GODVERSE/thriftgod shop census + OSM road geometry | `pipeline/godverse_town.py` (**Lane G owns this provenance**) | 🟢 ODbL 1.0 + GODVERSE census (G's own `license`/`attribution` fields) |
|
||||
| Town pack **⟨v5.0-FINAL⟩** | **21 real AU towns, all 8 states/territories** — **1196 shops** (299 heroes) + real street geometry (`roads[]`) | **OpenStreetMap** via Overpass API — bounded per-town bbox; raw shops+roads snapshots committed in `_raw/` | `build_towns.py`: fetch → dedupe/suburb-fill/parody → C's §6 class map → 3× texture cap (drops counted) → v2 cache + roads | 🟢 **ODbL 1.0** (© OSM contributors; `web/assets/towns/SOURCES.md` + `license`/`attribution` on every cache) |
|
||||
| Godverse towns *(Lane G's, listed for completeness)* **⟨v5.0-FINAL⟩** | `newtown_godverse` (72 shops) · **`redhill_godverse` (37)** — the town whose record shop is THE shop. Both rostered in E's `index.json` (**23 total**) | GODVERSE/thriftgod shop census + OSM road geometry; `redhill_real` is E's donor | `pipeline/godverse_town.py` (**Lane G owns this provenance**) | 🟢 ODbL 1.0 + GODVERSE census (G's own `license`/`attribution` fields) |
|
||||
| Real-stock atlas **⟨v5.0-FINAL⟩** | **1 crate, 120 items**, 2×2048² webp — Monster Robot Party (`3962749`) | **the real POS** (`recordgod`) — crate 550 "DEEP HOUSE"; covers are **the shop's own product shots**, cached by dealgod | `pipeline/godverse_stock.py` (**Lane G owns**) — `snapshot`(DB-side, sha256-pinned) → `pack`(pure) | 🟡 **in-house-green — FLAG BEFORE ANY PUBLIC/COMMERCIAL RELEASE** · `sourcing:"real"` · ids `sku_<POS id>` |
|
||||
| Mint atlases **⟨v5.0-FINAL⟩** | **14 crates, 224 items**, 14×1024² webp — keyed hero shops with **no POS** (5 record · 6 book · 3 toy across both godverse towns; the 6th record crate is the real one above) | **real dealgod listings** (the sellers' own product shots) — a *seeded sample*, `random.Random(shop_id)`, deterministic | `godverse_stock.py` mint baker (**Lane G owns**) — same bake path, sampled source | 🟡 **in-house-green — same flag** · `sourcing:"mint"` · ids `mint_<listing id>` · **never claimed as that shop's stock** |
|
||||
|
||||
**GLB fleet = 33 manifest (23 fit + 10 furniture) + 5 `_hi` = 38 published.** Only external spend ever:
|
||||
~$0.64 (fal-Hunyuan, R5). Everything else is $0 / on-device (electricity only).
|
||||
|
||||
### ⟨v5.0-FINAL⟩ The licence line's story — why one printed line is a provenance mechanism
|
||||
|
||||
**The only 🟡 in this table is the v5 stock art, and the flag is the whole control.** Charter law #3 says
|
||||
clearing photos for public release is **a human call** — so the gate does not pattern-match the licence
|
||||
and rule on it. It **prints it**, every run, for every atlas, and a human decides. That makes one printed
|
||||
line the mechanism the amber rows depend on, which is why it earned two rounds of work:
|
||||
|
||||
- **R23** — the gate globbed a name the runtime can never load: **0 files matched, returned 0**. It passed
|
||||
identically whether atlases were absent, misnamed, or perfect. (The vacuous-gate law came from this.)
|
||||
- **R25 — the line went silent and the gate still said OK.** Not a typo: the **check** read
|
||||
`licence or license` (permissive) while the **print** read `licence` only. G's re-emit moved to US
|
||||
`license`; the check passed, the print resolved to `{}`, and `FLAG BEFORE ANY PUBLIC/COMMERCIAL RELEASE`
|
||||
**stopped reaching a human on a real shop's product photos**. *The fallback WAS the bug* — it let one
|
||||
path stay permissive so it could not feel the other break.
|
||||
- **The fix is structural, not a spelling.** One spelling, no fallback (British `licence` now ERRORS,
|
||||
naming C's §7.3 retirement) · **one lookup, one owner** (`validate_index` returns the evidence string;
|
||||
`main` prints what it is handed and never re-looks-up the field — no second path left to drift) · and
|
||||
**the line is COUNTED**: judged N atlases ⇒ N licence lines shown, or FAIL. A gate that can say OK while
|
||||
hiding the flag cannot exist by construction.
|
||||
|
||||
**Today, frozen:** `atlas-QA OK — 15 per-shop atlas(es) valid, 15 licence line(s) shown, 0 warning(s)`.
|
||||
Fifteen crates, fifteen flags, every one in front of a human. **Both zones print** — the mint rows carry the
|
||||
same in-house-green flag because a seeded sample of real dealgod listings is still **the sellers' own
|
||||
product shots**. Minting changes whose stock it *claims* to be, never whose photograph it *is*: that is why
|
||||
`sourcing` is honesty and the licence is unchanged by it.
|
||||
|
||||
### ⟨v5.0-FINAL⟩ The id-space fences — provenance carried in the id itself
|
||||
|
||||
Two disjoint namespaces, blessed as design (C §7.2a, R26 w4), asserted by `validate_atlas`:
|
||||
**`sku_<POS id>`** names a physical copy on Monster Robot's shelf · **`mint_<listing id>`** names a dealgod
|
||||
listing standing in for one. A crate wearing the other's prefix **FAILS**. This is not naming hygiene:
|
||||
tier-2's sold-means-gone looks up POS skus, so a `mint_` id filed under `sku_` doesn't fail a gate — it
|
||||
**sells a real record out of a real shop to satisfy a minted stand-in**. G refused that shortcut when it
|
||||
would have gone green the easy way, and that judgment is the fence. *(Same standing note as
|
||||
plan-ids vs godverse-ids: one name, one space — never compare across.)*
|
||||
|
||||
### Audio inventory — 28 assets (`web/assets/audio/`, committed; contract = `manifest.audio`)
|
||||
|
||||
All procedural, seeded, $0, parody-safe; OGG/Opus + M4A/AAC; beds+music loudnorm −16 LUFS, SFX peak-norm.
|
||||
|
||||
@ -20,9 +20,17 @@ the "© OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL)" credit visible.
|
||||
**`index.json` is the machine-readable roster** (key/town/state/shops/roads) — read it rather than
|
||||
hardcoding a list. Every cache carries the same terms; per-town numbers live in each cache's `counts`.
|
||||
|
||||
**The pack: 21 real towns · 1196 shops · 299 heroes** (+ Lane G's `newtown_godverse` = 22 rostered in
|
||||
`index.json`), every one fetched from OSM Overpass with a bounded per-town bbox, ODbL 1.0, raw snapshots
|
||||
in `_raw/` (shops + roads per town), fetched 2026-07-16 (`redhill_real` 2026-07-17).
|
||||
**The pack: 21 real towns · 1196 shops · 299 heroes** (+ Lane G's `newtown_godverse` and `redhill_godverse`
|
||||
= **23 rostered** in `index.json`), every one fetched from OSM Overpass with a bounded per-town bbox, ODbL
|
||||
1.0, raw snapshots in `_raw/` (shops + roads per town), fetched 2026-07-16 (`redhill_real` 2026-07-17).
|
||||
|
||||
> **⟨v5.0-FINAL⟩ roster fix (R27):** `redhill_godverse` — the town the whole v5 epoch walks to — was **on
|
||||
> disk but missing from `index.json` for three rounds**. G's cache landed *after* my last `write_index()`
|
||||
> run and nobody re-rostered it. Every gate stayed green because `selfcheck` reads the directory directly
|
||||
> and F's smoke boots the town **by key**; only B's HUD selector reads this roster, so the sole symptom was
|
||||
> that **a player could not choose it from the dropdown**. Mine to own: the index is Lane E's, and an
|
||||
> addition isn't done when the cache is written — it's done when the roster is regenerated. (The mirror of
|
||||
> R24's lesson, where a *retirement* wasn't done until the consumers were swept.) See LANE_E_NOTES R27.
|
||||
|
||||
| state | towns |
|
||||
|---|---|
|
||||
|
||||
@ -144,7 +144,7 @@
|
||||
"key": "newtown_godverse",
|
||||
"town": "Newtown",
|
||||
"state": "",
|
||||
"shops": 18,
|
||||
"shops": 72,
|
||||
"roads": true,
|
||||
"source": "godverse+osm"
|
||||
},
|
||||
@ -164,6 +164,14 @@
|
||||
"roads": true,
|
||||
"source": "osm"
|
||||
},
|
||||
{
|
||||
"key": "redhill_godverse",
|
||||
"town": "Red Hill",
|
||||
"state": "",
|
||||
"shops": 37,
|
||||
"roads": true,
|
||||
"source": "godverse+osm"
|
||||
},
|
||||
{
|
||||
"key": "redhill_real",
|
||||
"town": "Red Hill",
|
||||
|
||||
Loading…
Reference in New Issue
Block a user