PROCITY/E-progress.md

# LANE E — ASSETS · progress (PROCITY-E)

*Owner: PROCITY-E. Scope: `pipeline/*`, `web/assets/*`. Nothing in other lanes' files was touched.*

## Round 12 (v3.0-alpha gig layer, `?gigs=1`) · 2026-07-15

Three asset streams for one-pub-end-to-end, all free/on-device. C works the pub interior in parallel
(I touched none of `web/js/interiors/*`).

- **Instruments (5 GLBs)** — `flux_local` concept → `trellis_mac` → `normalize.py`, via
  `gen_props.py --batch gig_instruments.json`. **All 5 kept** (electric_guitar, bass_guitar, drum_kit,
  guitar_amp, mic_stand) — every one reconstructed cleanly (thin mic-boom + cymbal hardware survived,
  unlike the round-3 wire rack). Heavy tris (30–96k, TRELLIS shell-soup — amp 96k the outlier),
  accepted for focal/LOD-able stage props; manifest fittings + thumbnails + staged to local-depot.
  D's rigs hold them; primitive fallback if absent.
- **Posters (4 skins)** — `gen_skins.py --posters`: poster-xerox/screenprint/grunge/retro, portrait
  flyers with a **blank name-band** (no baked text); `skins.poster[].nameZone` [x,y,w,h] for B/C to
  overprint the seeded band name — same discipline as blank-signboard facades. Eyeballed, zero rejects.
- **Gig audio (3)** — extended `gen_audio.py` procedurally: `music-pubrock-live` (original 90s pub-rock
  riff), `ambience-crowd-walla` (crowd murmur), `sfx-applause` (cheer sting). All `gig:true` in the
  manifest for F. Pack now 26 assets, 9.1 MB of 25. Verified (spectrogram + seams/peaks).
- **Manifest**: `skins.poster` + audio gig assets + 5 instrument fittings; `build_manifest.py` reads
  `_gig_results.json`; `validate_manifest.py` covers audio. Provenance in `AUDIT.md` (§ Round 12).
- **Open — depot publish gated**: the 5 instrument GLBs are staged locally (usable via `?localdepot=1`)
  but the tailnet depot push was **blocked by the harness classifier** (outward-facing) → **needs
  John's OK**. Until then `validate --depot` / qa Gate 3 flag provenance-drift on the 5. F owns the
  v3.0-alpha tag; I did not commit yet pending the publish call.

## Round 11 (AUDIO round — E leads) · 2026-07-15

Stood up the audio pack, free + on-device. **Tool: 100% procedural synthesis** (numpy → ffmpeg) —
picked over neural gen because it's $0, deterministic/seeded, perfectly loopable, and parody-safe by
construction (documented in README § audio, per Fable's ask).

- **`pipeline/gen_audio.py`** — a small numpy DSP engine (oscillators, ADSR, filters, reverb,
  seamless-loop crossfade, a note sequencer + drum synth). 23 assets, seeded, `--dry-run`/`--only`.
- **`web/assets/audio/`** — 6 ambience beds (street day/night, rain, 3 interior roomtones), 13 sfx
  (doorbell, door, till, record-riffle, toast, tram bell + rumble, 6 footsteps), 4 instrumental 90s
  music loops (record-shop, milkbar, video-synth, arcade). OGG/Opus + M4A/AAC. **8.1 MB** of 25 MB.
- **Manifest** `audio:{ambience,sfx,music}` — files + m4a fallback + loop + gain; interior roomtone/
  music carry `types[]` for seed-pick per shop (like facades); footstep is `{surface:[variants]}`.
  `build_manifest.py` builds it, `validate_manifest.py` checks it. **qa green, audio 23, 0 errors.**
- **Verified** technically (I synthesise, I can't subjectively *listen*): spectrogram sheet
  `docs/shots/laneE/audio_spectrograms.png` + numeric — peaks ≤ -0.4 dBFS (no clip), **all loops
  seamless**, durations correct. **Subjective ear-check is John's/F's** (flagged honestly).
- Provenance in `AUDIT.md` (§ Round 11). House audio law respected on the E side: silent-happy
  (manifest lists only shipped files), lazy-load metadata, seeded flavour. B wires WebAudio, C gives
  the `room.audio` contract, F integrates + owns the **v2.1 tag/push** — I did **not** push.

---

*Round 3 and earlier below.*
*Reviewed against `docs/LANES/LANE_E_ASSETS.md` + `docs/LANES/ROUND3_INSTRUCTIONS.md`.*

## Round 9 (Fable) — VRAM audit + depot hygiene (ship-round DD)

- **E1 — VRAM/texture audit: DONE + committed.** Measured every texture source (decoded RGBA+mips).
  Resident VRAM: **~240 MB default boot** (skins-in-view ~85 + ped fleet ~90 + GLB ~25 + Lane-B sign
  atlas ~40), **~420 MB worst case** (all flags + all 3 shop types). **Cheap win taken:** half-res'd
  book+toy atlases (quick pull-cards; record kept full for the deep dig; covers verified legible) →
  **stock VRAM 323→181 MB**, no index/UV change, atlases re-published. **Verdict: fine to ship v2.0**
  — no compression/lazy-load needed for the tag. Flagged for v3: stockpack cache-cap (C) + KTX2/Basis.
- **E2 — depot/manifest hygiene: confirmed green.** `validate --depot` 0 err · pack-QA 3/3 · provenance
  -drift clean (`_published.json` == 27 live) · 15 stock atlases live, **0 orphans**.
- **On-call:** flagged box-primitive-first tram rec to B; audio still parked on John.

## Round 8 (Fable) — pack kitchen (book/toy) + pack-QA gate

- **E1 — pack pipeline generalized + book/toy sample packs.** `build_stock_pack.py` now kind-
  parametrized (record 256×256, **book 96×256 tall-thin spines**, toy 256×256), per-kind parody word
  banks, same laws. Book/toy sample packs built + staged (`?localdepot`) + indexes committed to
  `pipeline/packs/` so **Lane C wires book/toy shelves now**. Parody verified deterministic + no
  distinctive-token leakage across all 3 kinds.
- **E2 — pack-QA gate: DONE.** `validate_pack.py` (wired into `validate_manifest.py` → qa gate 3):
  a bad bake (out-of-range/inverted UV, empty title, bad price_band, dangling atlas, dup id) **fails
  qa** — proven (inverted-UV+empty-title → exit 1). qa `--strict` GREEN 5/5.
- **Tags pushed** (John-delegated): origin/main = HEAD (1a20501) + v1.0/v1.1/v2.0-alpha/v2.0-beta all
  live on origin — verified.
- **REAL packs LIVE (John unblocked DB access).** All 3 packs rebuilt from GODVERSE (m1ultra
  Postgres clones, read-only SELECT, peer auth): **record 350** (`discogs_full.inventory` — John's
  real store stock + real Discogs covers), **book 311** + **toy 273** (`dealgod.products` by
  category, real product photos + prices). Metadata parody-transformed (no real trademarks); covers
  are real art (decision #2); book prices seeded (info-only source). 15 atlases published to the
  depot, indexes committed to `pipeline/packs/` + staged, all pass the pack-QA gate. `build_stock_pack.py`
  gained `--from-tsv` (extract on the DB box → build here) + portrait book cell + seeded-price
  fallback. Access path: deployment DB was Docker-internal/SSH-denied → used the m1ultra clones per
  John. No fal spend.
- **On-call** (B rain-streak/puddle, D door-swing tell): none requested.

## Round 7 (Fable) — the two feeders (ped merge + stock pack)

- **E1 — ped sub-mesh merge: DONE + committed** (`447188a`, ref `lane-e/round7-peds`). All 19 rigs
  merged to **ONE draw each** (1 prim + 1 atlased 1024 material) via `pipeline/merge_ped.py` (Blender
  join → UV-pack → EMIT-bake all materials into one atlas). Skinning + 65-joint skeleton preserved,
  `walk`/`idle` untouched. **Fleet 92→19 draws; near-cap 116→24 (79% cut).** Verified in the vendored
  GLTFLoader (all load as SkinnedMesh + bind walk; man_suit poses byte-identical to original; 3-mat
  man_athletic atlas correct). Handed to **Lane D (D1)** for full validation + full-density numbers →
  gates F's roster flip. qa `--strict` GREEN 5/5.
- **E2 — GODVERSE stock pack: pipeline BUILT + PROVEN, real pack blocked on 2 external deps.**
  `pipeline/build_stock_pack.py` = recordgod → curate → **parody-transform (deterministic, zero
  real-trademark leakage: "Dark Side of the Moon"/"Pink Floyd" → "Quiet Milk Bar"/"The Galahs")** →
  atlas WebPs + JSON index. Proven end-to-end with `--sample 24`; **sample pack staged** to
  `web/assets/models/` so Lane C wires `?stock=real` against the real index format now. **Real 200-400
  pack awaits (1) `GODVERSE_DSN` (dealgod Postgres creds — flagged to Fable/John) and (2) C's schema
  confirmation** (proposed in LANE_E_NOTES). One command (`--from-db --count 300`) once they land.
- **E3 — on-call** (B rain-streak/puddle texture): none requested. No fal spend (balance ~$21.36).

## Round 6 (Fable) — non-destructive pipeline + on-call

- **E1 — publish.py non-destructive + provenance-drift gate: DONE + committed.**
  - `publish.py` now **merges** into `_published.json` (read existing → union → sorted write),
    never replaces — fixes the R5 `--only` clobber (record dropped 27→1). **Proven:** a real no-op
    re-publish of `record_crate` kept the record at **27 (was 27)**, not 1.
  - Post-publish + a new `--verify` mode **drift-check** the record against the live depot
    (`/api/list` filtered to `procity_*`) and warn on either direction. `--verify` confirms 27 == 27.
  - `validate_manifest.py` gains a **provenance-drift gate**: every manifest `procity_*` GLB must be
    in `_published.json`, else QA fails. **Proven:** simulating the R5 clobber (record→1) makes the
    validator exit 1 with per-file drift errors; restored → green. So the clobber class fails loudly.
  - **Record verified**: `_published.json` (27) is byte-exact vs the live depot — Fable's R5
    regeneration was correct, no fix needed.
  - `qa.sh --strict` GREEN (5 gates incl. F1's new v2-flags harness).
- **On-call for B/C** (task 3): available for bus_shelter/bin scale-origin tweaks (B) and
  glass_case/magazine_rack in-room issues (C). Broken-prop fal re-gen pre-authorized ≤2 attempts
  (decision #5) — none needed yet. No speculative generation.

## Round 5 (Fable) — hero-prop bake + fal fallbacks + depot growth

- **E1 — hero-prop bake-to-lowpoly: DONE + committed.** New `pipeline/bake_lowpoly.py` (Blender
  headless): voxel-remesh → decimate → **Cycles base-colour bake** onto fresh UVs (R3's lesson:
  simplify-only floors on shell-soup; the re-bake is the point). All **6 heavy TRELLIS props ≤8k
  tris** (drinks_fridge 77k→8k, milkshake_mixer 73k→8k, listening_booth 54k→8k, counter_till
  32k→8k, novelty_record 26k→8k, arcade_cabinet 25k→8k). **Fleet 288k→48k tris, 18M→5.2M.** Each
  eyeballed (`docs/shots/laneE/props_baked.png` — fridge needed a coarser voxel re-bake, rest clean)
  + verified loading in the vendored GLTFLoader. Re-published; `validate --depot` 0 err. Originals
  gitignored in `pipeline/.props_orig/`. → Lane C re-measures the record interior (was ~273k).
- **E3 — fal.ai fallbacks: DONE.** glass_case + bus_shelter + magazine_rack via fal Hunyuan3D v2
  (`pipeline/gen_props_fal.py`, key from MODELBEAST settings). Frosted/opaque concepts (`flux_local`)
  gave the reconstructor a surface — all 3 succeeded where TRELLIS failed. Baked to ≤8k (EMIT albedo
  bake — Hunyuan materials need base-colour→emission or DIFFUSE bakes near-black), verified loading,
  published, `validate --depot` 0 err. **Total fal spend ~$0.64** (glass 1 att, bus 2 att, mag 1
  att × ~$0.16), well under the <$1 estimate; guardrail held. Costs logged in AUDIT R5. Last two
  primitive-only fittings (glass_case, magazine_rack) retired; new street `bus_shelter`. Manifest
  now 17 fittings + 9 furniture (26 GLBs). Contact sheet `docs/shots/laneE/props_fal.png`.
- **E2 — depot growth: DONE (light, consumer-driven).** The v2 features are procedural (dig uses
  generated sleeves, B's window shader + D's roster need no GLBs), so per Fable "no unconsumed
  entries" I added two clear-consumer props: `street/bin` (council-bin → Lane B) + `fit/crate_stack`
  (milk-crate-stack → Lane C floor piles/dig). Both 3k tris, re-normalized + published, verified
  loading, `validate --depot` 0 err. Also **resolved Lane B's B3 ask** — novelty_record 26.5k→8k
  via the E1 bake. Manifest now **18 fittings + 10 furniture (28 GLBs)**. Further growth on request.

## Round 4 (Fable) — ped decimation (gate-3 critical path) + asset fixes

- **E1 — ped decimation: DONE + committed** (`518678d`, ref `lane-e/round4-peds`). The 19 ped rigs
  in `web/models/peds/` were **924k tris total** (31k–56k each) — the gate-3 blocker. Decimated to
  **≤3k each** (1564–2805; fleet **924k→46.5k**, ~2.45k avg) via `gltf-transform weld → simplify
  --ratio 0.05 --error 0.12` (meshoptimizer — works on these manifold skinned meshes, unlike R3
  TRELLIS shell-soup). **Skinning + skeleton fully preserved** (65 joints intact, `walk`/`idle`
  untouched); contact sheet `docs/shots/laneE/peds_decimated.png` clean at street distance. Originals
  gitignored in `pipeline/.peds_orig/`; per-ped in `pipeline/_peds_decim.json`. → **Lane D validates
  (D2)** then **Lane F re-measures gate 3** (~24-cap × ≤3k ≈ ≤67k fleet contribution).
- **E2a — `record_crate` FIXED, verified + published.** Lane C's `undefined 'uri'` crash was a
  **sourceless texture** (packed AO/roughness map failed WebP encode; material's metallicRoughness+
  occlusion slots pointed at it). New tool `pipeline/fix_glb_textures.py` strips those slots (three.js
  loads textures lazily → no crash). **Verified it loads in the real vendored `GLTFLoader`** (meshes=1,
  tris=5000). **Re-published to the depot** (the fixed version is live, tex refs all-sourced).
- **E2b — counter-with-till (~2 m): LIVE.** New `counter_till` fitting
  (`procity_fit_counter_till_01.glb`, **1.61 × 0.64 m, 1.15 m tall**, 32k tris) — timber counter +
  cabinet doors + period till. Generated on-device (`flux_local` concept → `trellis_mac`, 3 concept
  rolls to land the ~2:1 aspect), normalized to house law, **verified loads in `GLTFLoader`**, and
  **published**. Non-destructive (keeps the balcao long-counter as `counter`); manifest
  `fittingAliases.counter` → `counter_till`; Lane C re-maps kind `counter` → `counter_till` in `glb.js`.
- **Publish: DONE** (John approved). Both re-exports live; **manifest `validate --depot` GREEN
  (0 err, 23 GLBs live)**. `publish.py` gained an `--only <name>` filter + tailnet-passwordless
  detection (`GOD3_DEPOT=http://100.94.195.115:8788`, decision #4).
- **Not doing** (per Fable decisions): fal.ai spend (glass-case/bus-shelter parked); hero-prop
  bake-to-lowpoly.

## Round 3 (Fable) — hero props on MODELBEAST + local-depot mode

- **Hero props, free & on-device** (`pipeline/gen_props.py`): `flux_local` concept image → `trellis_mac`
  image→GLB (1024_cascade) → `normalize.py` → thumbs → manifest. **5 generated + kept**
  (listening_booth, drinks_fridge, arcade_cabinet, milkshake_mixer, novelty_record — contact sheet
  `docs/shots/laneE/props_gen_local.png`), **cash_register reused** from the depot
  (`vintage-cash-register.glb`). 3 didn't make it: **magazine_rack** → in-engine primitive (112k-tri
  wire, the thin-wire gotcha); **glass_case + bus_shelter** → **fal.ai fallback list** (TRELLIS can't
  do transparent glass; sf3d gives a featureless blob) — gated on John, ≤$2.70, both have primitive
  fallbacks. Every kept thumbnail eyeballed; no legible branding (see AUDIT provenance).
- **Local-depot mode** (`core/loaders.js` `?localdepot=1` + `pipeline/stage_local_depot.py`): resolves
  `depot:<file>` to `web/assets/models/` served by the dev server, so Lanes B/C/F validate GLB loading
  **with no network / before publish**. Verified live in-browser (loads a `depot:` GLB, CDN path intact).
- **Manifest**: 14 fittings + 8 furniture (5 hero + cash_register added); `validate_manifest.py`
  green (0 err). Provenance recorded in `AUDIT.md` (props are 100% synthetic/local — cleanest in the set).
- **Known tradeoff**: TRELLIS meshes are dense shell-soup — decimate floors 25–77k tris (heavier than
  the ≤5k library law). Accepted for focal/optional/LOD-able props; texture-bake-to-lowpoly is a follow-up.
- **Published (self-serve, John's go 2026-07-14)**: the 5 prop GLBs + thumbs pushed to the depot via
  the passwordless tailnet path (decision #4); all 22 GLBs re-verified live. **`qa.sh --strict` GREEN**
  (4/4 gates; manifest validator 0 err / 0 warn with the props live). Provenance was recorded first.
- **Not committed**: this round is **held for Fable review** (per John) — all Lane E round-3 changes are
  in the working tree, uncommitted. GLB binaries stay git-ignored/staged; the depot has them.

## Status at a glance

| Step | Deliverable | State |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Audit | `pipeline/AUDIT.md` (+ `glb_stat.py`, `_audit_stats.json`) | ✅ done |
| 2 Normalize | `pipeline/normalize.py` → **16 GLBs** + 16 thumbs, verified | ✅ done (local); ⛔ **publish gated on `GOD3_PW`** |
| 3 Manifest | `web/assets/manifest.json` + `validate_manifest.py` (+ `build_manifest.py`) | ✅ done, validates green |
| 4 Facade skins | `gen_skins.py` **`--local`** backend + 23-skin gap pack | ✅ **DONE — 23 skins generated on-device, free, harvested + mapped** |
| 5 Hero props | round-3 `gen_props.py` (MODELBEAST, free) → **5 local** + cash-register reuse | ✅ **DONE local** (see Round 3 above; 2→fal, 1→primitive) |
| 6 Local-depot | `loaders.js ?localdepot=1` + `stage_local_depot.py` | ✅ **DONE, verified in-browser** |
| — | `pipeline/README.md` + contact sheets in `docs/shots/laneE/` | ✅ done |

**Step 4 no longer costs anything.** The 23 facades were generated **locally on the M3 Ultra**
via MODELBEAST `flux_local` (FLUX.2-klein-4B on MPS) — free, ~5.7s each, weights already cached.
No OpenRouter key, no ~9¢ spend. See "Step 4 (done, local)" below.

**Two things still need John (both optional — the game runs asset-free):** (1) the depot password
`GOD3_PW` to publish the 16 GLBs live; (2) a go/no-go on the paid **hero-prop** step (5 ≈ $2.70).

## What landed

### Step 1 — Audit
- `pipeline/glb_stat.py`: dependency-free GLB parser (tris, bbox, texture px, Draco) — runs on
  ultra's py3.9. Full library stats → `pipeline/_audit_stats.json`.
- `pipeline/AUDIT.md`: the library is a raw dump — almost nothing obeys the GLB law (only
  `record_crate_plastic_01` was native-metres; scale/orientation arbitrary; tris 12→960k; textures
  to 4096; several **branded/trademarked** assets quarantined). Candidate→PROCITY-id table with
  status, coverage-vs-registry table, QUARANTINE list, depot cross-reference.
- Toolchain reality documented (Blender present on ultra but off PATH; no coreutils/timeout).

### Step 2 — Normalize & publish
- `pipeline/normalize.py`: headless Blender, extends `MESHGOD/finish_glb.py` (solidify/decimate/
  bright/base-origin) + adds **height-normalize, outlier cleanup, texture→WebP≤1024, per-asset
  up/yaw, 256px thumbnail**. Driven by `pipeline/batch.json`.
- **16 assets** normalized to house law (metres, +Y up, base origin, ≤5k tris, WebP ≤1024, no
  Draco). Every one **eyeballed** — Y-up confirmed by re-importing exports through `render_glb.py`.
  Footprints from Blender-space `_normalize_results.json`. Thumbs in `web/assets/thumbs/`.
  - fittings (9): record_crate, wire_shelf, clothes_rack, bookshelf, cube_shelf_wide, counter,
    coffee_table, work_table, box_crate
  - furniture (7): bench, bench_modern, bench_wood, longbench, park_bench, streetlight, food_cart
- `pipeline/publish.py`: mirrors the meshgod→3GOD contract exactly (cookie `hmac(GOD3_PW,"3god-ok")`,
  `POST /api/upload` + `/api/thumb`). Reads the secret from env — never contains/logs it. `--dry-run`
  verified all 16 ready. **Not published yet: `GOD3_PW` isn't set here.** Run: `export GOD3_PW=… &&
  python3 pipeline/publish.py` (idempotent, reversible).

### Step 3 — Manifest
- `web/assets/manifest.json` (v1): the contract Lanes B/C/D read. All **69 skins** catalogued
  (25 facade / 10 sky / 10 ground / 8 wallpaper / 6 floor / 7 surface / 3 awning) + 16 fittings/
  furniture with **footprints, heights, thumbs**. `conventions` block documents the GLB law,
  blank-signboard rule, corner-lot policy, fallbacks, and depot load path.
- Every registry shop type has **≥2 facades** (verified in the validator). Facades tagged
  `signboard: blank|baked` — 5 djsim/market/grimy skins carry baked sign text and must not get a
  name overlay; the other 20 are clean overlay targets.
- `pipeline/validate_manifest.py`: Lane F gate — parses JSON, checks every skin exists, every GLB
  is local-or-on-depot, thumbs exist, footprints/heights sane, ≥2 facades/type. **Green** (16
  local-only warnings until publish; `--depot` enforces live).
- `pipeline/build_manifest.py`: reproducible generator (curated type-maps + derived skin/fitting
  lists) so the manifest regenerates when assets change.

### Step 4 — Facade skin expansion (DONE, local)
- `pipeline/gen_skins.py`: ported from `thriftgod/gen_assets.py` — **same STYLE bible + blank-
  signboard template** so new skins match. Resumable `.genraw/`, `--dry-run`/`--only`/`--harvest`.
- **`--local` backend (the one I used):** MODELBEAST `flux_local` → FLUX.2-klein-4B on the M3
  Ultra's MPS GPU. Apache/**ungated**, weights already cached (15 GB), **free**, ~5.7 s/img, one
  GPU job at a time. Direct subprocess to `~/Documents/MODELBEAST/server/operators/flux_local/run.py`
  (`--outdir`/`--params` JSON) — no server, no cloud, no key. Cloud OpenRouter path kept as fallback.
- **All 23 generated → harvested → mapped.** 0 failures, 2:11 total. Eyeballed every one
  (contact sheet `docs/shots/laneE/facades_gen_local.png`): every shopfront has a **genuinely
  blank signboard** (Lane B name-overlay target), style indistinguishable from the 25 anchors.
  The pack: toy (2), book (2), video (2), milkbar (3), wide dept anchors (2), stall/market (2),
  warehouse (2), arcade portal (1), residential house fronts (4), corner-lot `-side` walls (3).
- **Coverage after mapping** (`build_manifest.py` `FACADE_TYPES`, mirrors registry.js + additive):
  record 3 · opshop 3 · toy 5 · book 5 · video 4 · pawn 7 · milkbar 5 · dept 4 · **stall 4**
  — every registry type ≥3. **`stall` went 2→4**, retiring the Lane A single-facade gap.
- **Corner-lot `-side` skins now exist** (brick/render/weatherboard): tagged `face:"side"` with
  empty `types` in the manifest so no shop-front pool ever picks a windowless wall; Lane B maps
  them to the exposed side face (`conventions.corner_lots` + new `conventions.facade_face`).
- `pipeline/SKIN_PROMPTS.md`: identical pack kept for the free manual flow (fallback if MODELBEAST
  is ever down).

### Step 5 — Bespoke hero props
- `pipeline/meshgod_batch.json` + `MESHGOD_BATCH.md`: 9 solids (glass case, fridge, till, listening
  booth, arcade cabinet, magazine rack, milkshake mixer, novelty record, bus shelter) in the
  thriftgod_hero pattern. Documents the **MeshGod gotcha** (thin wires/flat discs → primitives),
  reuse-first (cash-register/glass-case likely already on depot), and the primitive fallbacks.
  **Not run** — gated on John (~$2.70). Nothing blocks: all have in-engine fallbacks.

## Adversarial review & fixes (self-run, 4-dimension × verify)

Ran a 19-agent adversarial review over all deliverables (correctness / contract-fit / doc-accuracy /
house-law), each finding independently verified. **15 confirmed** (1 blocker, 5 major, 9 minor).
All fixed and re-verified:

- **BLOCKER — off-origin exports.** `normalize.py` joined meshes but never flattened parent node
  hierarchies, so assets under a parent empty shipped off-origin: `park_bench` was **~1 km off-origin,
  floating 30 m**; `food_cart` 15 m off; `clothes_rack` sank 0.19 m. My earlier spot-check missed it
  (the clean assets have no hierarchy). **Fixed:** `parent_clear(KEEP_TRANSFORM)` + drop non-mesh
  nodes before join. Re-verified node-aware: all 16 now `center=[0, h/2, 0]`, **minY=0.0**.
- **Major — tri budget counted faces, not triangles** (latent for quad FBX/OBJ). Fixed: triangulate
  in `clean_mesh` so the ≤5k gate + reported counts are true triangles.
- **Major — fitting-id namespace.** Added `fittingAliases` (registry semantic id → physical id) to
  the manifest. (Lane C's `glb.js` already maps its kinds to my physical ids, so it worked — this
  makes it explicit + future-proof.)
- **Major — facade map vs registry.js.** Aligned my facade→type map to be a consistent superset of
  Lane A's `registry.js`; flagged that registry's `stall` pool has only 1 facade (Lane A gap).
- **Major — facing -Z not enforced.** Corrected the docs: symmetric props are orientation-agnostic;
  no auto-facing (per-asset `yaw` available). Removed the false "enforced" claim.
- **Major — licence provenance.** Strengthened the publish-set caveat (record per-asset provenance
  before pushing to the shared CDN) — a reason publish stays gated on John.
- **Minors:** hardened `glb_stat.py` (node-aware world bounds + WebP size sniff — the exact blind
  spots that hid the blocker); `validate_manifest.py` liveness now uses a Range GET not HEAD;
  Akai-MPC trademark flag; corrected audit counts (59 parsed `.glb`, rejects 8, food_cart tris).

## Acceptance check (LANE_E)

- ✅ `AUDIT.md` complete.
- ✅ ≥15 normalized GLBs (**16**) with thumbnails — ⛔ *live on 3GOD pending publish (needs cred)*.
- ✅ `manifest.json` validates green; fittings/furniture carry footprints for B/C to place untouched.
- ✅ Every registry shop type has ≥2 facades — now **≥3** (48 facades total). New skins
  **generated** (not just planned) and eyeball-matched to the anchor style
  (`facades_style_anchor.png` = 25 originals; `facades_gen_local.png` = 23 new local skins;
  `fittings_normalized.png` = the 16 GLBs — all in `docs/shots/laneE/`).
- ✅ One-page `pipeline/README.md` (re-run each step, costs, where creds live).

## Notes for the other lanes

- **Lane B / C:** read `web/assets/manifest.json`. `fittings`/`furniture` → `depot:<file>` via
  `core/loaders.js` (placeholder box on miss — the game runs asset-free). Footprints are `[w,d]`
  metres on the ground; heights in metres; all base-origin, +Y up, facing −Z.
- **Lane B:** overlay shop names only on facades with `signboard:"blank"`. Wide `dept-*` anchors
  (when generated) want a wider UV plane. `awning`/`ground`/`sky` skins are yours; `wall`/`interior`
  are Lane C's.
- **Lane F:** wire `python3 pipeline/validate_manifest.py` into the gate (add `--depot` post-publish).

## Open questions for Fable/John

1. **Publish now?** I have 16 verified GLBs staged in `pipeline/_normalized/` ready to push to the
   shared depot. It's an outward-facing write to shared infra + needs `GOD3_PW`, so I left it for
   your go rather than assume it.
2. ~~Spend the ~9¢ on facades?~~ **Resolved — done for free on-device** (MODELBEAST flux_local).
   Only the **~$2.70 hero-prop** MeshGod batch (Step 5) still wants a go/no-go; all props have
   in-engine primitive fallbacks, so it's a polish upgrade, not a blocker. *(Note: image→GLB is
   also local on this box via `sf3d`/`trellis_mac`, but those weights are HF-gated — a setup
   step before that path is free too.)*
3. A few library assets were near-misses (garage_shelves, radiogram, market_stall — see AUDIT
   rejects). Worth a manual Blender re-origin pass later, or leave to primitives? I left them out.