Two bugs in the acceptance test, both found by running it for real.
1. THE GATE DID NOT APPLY TO TEXTURED RUNS. The texture path returned before the
check, so the one path most likely to be used for real assets was the only one that
could ship a blob silently. The check is now a shared gate() called from both.
2. THE METRIC WAS TESSELLATION-DEPENDENT. It projected the VERTEX LIST, so a decimated
mesh sampled its own silhouette more sparsely and scored lower for an identical
shape - holes appear inside the outline and count as misses. Measured on two real
assets:
asset verts vertex-proj surface-sampled
1_img (gate FAILED) 133,842 0.790 0.911
0_img (gate passed) 227,546 0.965 0.969
The dense mesh barely moves; the sparse one jumps 0.12. That is the metric
measuring tessellation, not accuracy - and at min_iou 0.85 it had just rejected a
good reconstruction. Overlay confirmed it: the "missing" region was speckle inside
the silhouette, not a wrong shape.
Now samples 3M points uniformly over the surface, so density is a constant of the
metric rather than a property of the mesh.
Worth stating plainly: the gate caught a real problem on its first live failure - just
not the one it reported. A quality gate that is itself unvalidated is a liability, and
this one needed the same "measure it, do not reason about it" treatment as the model.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
||
|---|---|---|
| pixal3d_mlx | ||
| scripts | ||
| tests | ||
| .gitignore | ||
| CLAUDE.md | ||
| README.md | ||
| silhouette_check.png | ||
pixal3d_mrp_mlx
MLX port of Pixal3D (TencentARC + Tsinghua, SIGGRAPH 2026, MIT) — pixel-aligned single-image 3D generation — for Apple Silicon.
Built on trellis_sparse_mlx, the shared TRELLIS-lineage
sparse core. Pixal3D and LATO.2 inherit the same sparse module from TRELLIS.2, so the
expensive part — submanifold sparse convolution, which has no Metal implementation — is
already done and tested there.
Why Pixal3D
It back-projects pixel features directly into 3D rather than injecting them through attention, so silhouettes stay exact to the source image. Different failure mode from TRELLIS/Hunyuan, and complementary to them.
Upstream needs ~24 GB VRAM, which is a wall on consumer Nvidia and a non-issue on a 128 GB+ Ultra.
Scope, measured against the shared core
| Need | Status |
|---|---|
SparseConv3d — every call is (c, out, 3), i.e. stride=1/padding=None → SubMConv3d |
✅ in shared core |
attn_mode='full' (the only mode used) |
✅ in shared core |
SparseLinear, norms, activations, ResBlock, transformer blocks |
✅ in shared core |
SparseDownsample(2) |
✅ in shared core |
VarLenTensor / SparseTensor split + get/register_spatial_cache |
✅ added to shared core |
dense nn.Conv3d(.., 2, stride=2) in sparse_structure_vae |
✅ maps to mlx.nn.Conv3d |
SparseUpsample(2) |
❌ to do — cache-paired inverse of a downsample |
SparseSpatial2Channel(2) |
❌ to do — sparse pixel-shuffle, spatial→channel |
Both of those are now done in the shared core.
Correction to the earlier scope
"the gap is two ops" was accurate about modules/sparse/ — the sparse primitives. It
undercounted the model blocks, which the configs revealed:
| Still needed | Where |
|---|---|
| RoPE positional embedding | all 4 flow models (pe_mode: "rope") — but rope_phases ships as a stored tensor, so phases are precomputed, not derived |
qk_rms_norm on q and k |
all 4 flow models |
AdaLN modulation (share_mod: true) |
all 4 flow models |
image_attn_mode: "proj" conditioning |
all 4 flow models |
SparseConvNeXtBlock3d |
shape_dec, tex_dec |
SparseResBlockC2S3d (channel↔spatial) |
shape_dec, tex_dec — uses SparseSpatial2Channel |
Offsetting that, a genuine simplification the tensors revealed: the four flow models
(~20 GB, the bulk of the download) contain ZERO 5-D tensors. ss_flow and the three
slat_flow DiTs are pure transformers — they never touch sparse convolution, so they
need none of the sparse core, just DiT blocks.
Model surface
pixal3d/models/
sparse_structure_vae.py dense Conv3d — voxel structure
sparse_structure_flow.py structure flow (SS)
structured_latent_flow.py SLAT flow
sc_vaes/sparse_unet_vae.py the only file using sparse conv
Weights: 24.04 GB across 19 files (1.3B DiTs at 512/1024 + shape/tex decoders).
Status
- Scoped against the shared core
- Weights downloaded (24 GB) — each ships a sibling
.jsonwith the exact config, so unlike LATO.2 there is no architecture to infer upsample(masked) +downsample(mode=)landed in the shared core- Weight converter — decoders remap KRSC→
[K³,in,out], dtype preserved, remap verified a pure permutation. Flow models pass through untouched. - DiT blocks: RoPE (stored complex phases), qk_rms_norm, AdaLN modulation, proj conditioning
- All four flow models verified against upstream at correlation 1.00000000
—
ss_flow(max diff 1.2e-5) andslat_flow(9.3e-6), 700/700 params each, on the real 1.3B checkpoints SparseConvNeXtBlock3d,SparseResBlockC2S3d,spatial2channel/channel2spatial— all in the shared core, round-trip and selective-growth testedss_decverified at correlation 1.00000000 (74/74), completing the whole structure stage: image -> ss_flow -> latent -> ss_dec -> 64^3 occupancy gridshape_dec/tex_dec— both load complete (292/292, 284/284) and run. Behaviourally checked only; see the verification note below- Proj conditioning — camera back-projection, an exact
grid_sampleequivalent, and DINOv3 (torch/MPS). All four extractor stages diffed against upstream at correlation 1.00000000 - NAF high-res branch without natten — natten is unusable on Apple Silicon
(no
libnatten;flex-fnais CPU-only, rejects asymmetric head dims, and was OOM-killed at 512). Replaced by an exact reduction to a clamped 9x9 low-res neighbourhood, verified against natten at 7.15e-07 - The full cascade — 32^3 -> LR SLAT -> coord refinement -> 64^3 HR SLAT -> Flexible Dual Grid at 1024^3 -> GLB, at silhouette IoU 0.969
- Mesh cleanup — weld, strip floaters, iterative decimation (500k faces at IoU 0.965; ~214k is a hard floor, see below)
- MODELBEAST operator
pixal3d_mlx(geometry only) - Texture stage (tex SLAT + o_voxel PBR bake) — the GLB is currently untextured
Running it
python scripts/image_to_mesh.py IMAGE -o out.glb --target-faces 500000
Exits non-zero below --min-iou (default 0.85): a run that completes with a
reconstruction that does not track the input has failed, even though nothing raised.
Mesh quality, measured
| face budget | result | silhouette IoU |
|---|---|---|
| raw decoder output | 7,996,876 | 0.969 |
| 500,000 | 499,984 | 0.965 |
| 200,000 / 100,000 / 20,000 | 214,322 (floor) | 0.823 |
~214k is a hard floor. The Flexible Dual Grid emits ~180,000 boundary edges for
open surfaces and quadric decimation will not collapse those — no target_reduction
or agg setting changes it, and a single fast_simplification call additionally
refuses to reduce past ~4.4% of its input (hence the iterative loop). Going lower
needs a remesh; o_voxel's ran >20 minutes on 214k faces before being killed, so it is
not currently a practical route. 500k is effectively lossless — use that.
Model status
| model | params | verification |
|---|---|---|
ss_flow |
700/700 | corr 1.00000000 vs upstream |
slat_flow x3 |
700/700 | corr 1.00000000 vs upstream |
ss_dec |
74/74 | corr 1.00000000 vs upstream |
shape_dec |
292/292 | behavioural only — no oracle possible |
tex_dec |
284/284 | behavioural only — no oracle possible |
The split is not arbitrary: the first five contain no sparse convolution, so upstream runs on CPU torch and can be diffed directly. The two decoders do use it, spconv has no Metal build, and so there is nothing to diff against. Their blocks are individually tested, and the assembled graphs are checked for complete weight mapping, selective growth, correct scale and a vertex head inside its valid band — but that is weaker evidence than a correlation and should be read that way.
Numerical verification
The flow models contain no sparse convolution, which means upstream runs on CPU torch
here — swap flash-attn for F.scaled_dot_product_attention and it loads the real
checkpoint and runs. So unlike the sparse path (where spconv is uninstallable and the
oracle had to be hand-written), these are diffed against upstream directly:
MLX : mean +0.18490 std 0.86841
UPSTREAM : mean +0.18490 std 0.86841
max abs diff 1.216e-05 correlation 1.00000000
Getting there required finding three bugs that weight-key matching could not catch — the loader reported a perfect 700/700 with 0 missing and 0 unmapped through all of them:
- A parameterless final
LayerNormbetween the last block andout_layer. It has no weights, so it leaves no trace in the checkpoint. Without it the output was ~200x too large (std 187 vs 0.87). rope_phasesis complex64, built withtorch.polar. The rotation is a complex multiply and cos/sin are the phase's real/imaginary parts — takingcos()of a complex phase is meaningless.- qk RMS norm is applied BEFORE RoPE, not after. They do not commute. Reversed, a single block still correlated 0.9998 with upstream; over 30 blocks that compounds to 0.84. This one is invisible without an oracle.