The scoring quantity is the FLOWN garden state now, not static cover%.
New gardenfly.js: windForSite (C's shared builder — venturi + shelters, one
copy in the repo) → real attach (throws on D's skipped-attach trap) → skyfx
exposure → garden.js, per candidate line; cover% demoted to a labelled
geometry diagnostic. audit.html flies every affordable line + bare bed and
judges the site's pinned separation block on the block's own storm; audit.mjs
(node) keeps fast winnability, gains p5 in its verified dump, and points at
the browser for garden truth.
On C's correction, three structural adoptions:
- windForSite everywhere (three harnesses independently mis-built site wind;
no fourth copy);
- LIVE anchors via the re-pointable wind proxy — the audit's own frozen-sway
remap was C's landmine 2 wearing my file's name (audit.html:69);
- the MARGIN rule (AUDIT.MARGIN = 0.15, one copy): every row prices twice —
$hw holds vs $cleanHw with >=15% headroom — and only clean lines are
winners; verdict code 'marginal-only' when the budget can only buy the
knife edge (D's 39.8-TATTERED wild night, C's dead 91.9 headline).
Also game-true flight: the phantom 12s calm settle is GONE from the sweep
(commit->attach->storm is one keypress; the settle skewed every storm sample
12 s off the authored curve — SailRig samples wind at its INTERNAL clock).
That skew is not academic: it is a.test's separation-flight harness too, and
gardenfly.selftest now pins BOTH chains (game-true 63.8 tattered vs skewed
68.4 'full' on the pinned p5 line — the disagreement is flagged to A in
THREADS, not overruled here). The pinned recipe also sweeps regardless of the
18-45 band (it is 45.9 m² — the band predates p5; flagged to A).
Selftest 356/0/0 on the scratch merge (b+a+c@45bdc2d). Mutation-checked:
MARGIN=0 reddens the margin test (node); dropping siteDef from gardenfly's
windForSite call reddens the venturi test (browser, exact test named).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
audit.mjs's hand-typed backyard dump goes full-precision: the 2-dp rounding
moved t2 ~5 mm against t1's shelter cone and swung its ice-night peak
4.8 -> 9.3 kN — the node and browser front-ends disagreed by one whole
winnable line until the positions matched to the float. Reconciled by
measurement (node on full floats reproduces the browser exactly).
Re-audit verdict (THREADS, full tables): every night still passes, no retune
proposed — E's numbers stand. backyard: hints move exactly one number (night
2 honest $30 -> $40; fascia appears in zero bed-covering quads so its 0.35
is audit-invisible). site_02: 64/66 -> 23/66 affordable, every cheap carport
line dead, cheapest now $40 honest steel, cheapest >=70% line $45 through a
$30-rated carport post — the trap is priced, not fenced off.
Selftest 319/0/0.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
sail.js _checkFailure now fails a corner on load > hw.rating * anchor.ratingHint
(read live from the anchor — dress() mutates in place). Consequence asserted,
not the formula: on site_02's carport line (uniform rated shackles, funnel on,
12 s calm settle) a cb corner blows before any q corner — at DEFAULT tension
(t~29 s into the storm, honest posts hold) and at max. In-suite control pins
the attribution: the same rig with every hint forced to 1 holds 4/4, so the
break is the hint, not the load. Mutation-checked: unwiring the line fails both.
rigging.js weak-link (D's #7): summary.weakest reduces on rating * ratingHint
via _effRating, not bare hw.rating — uniform hardware now flags the genuinely
worst steel instead of the first click. Mutation-checked.
site_audit prices the anchor, not just the steel: tierFor(peak, hint) needs
h.rating * hint >= peak, both front-ends carry ratingHint through (browser off
world.anchors, node dump extended with the live-dumped hints), rows print the
hint. sweep.selftest asserts hints reprice without touching peaks and land
over-ceiling corners in unholdable. Mutation-checked.
Selftest 319/0/0 (315 + 4).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
site_audit's headless false-negative is fixed by the browser front-end
(A's loadSite/createWorld landed in main — that was all it waited on), and
fixing it surfaced a worse bug underneath: the sweep built its wind from the
STORM def alone and never called setVenturi, which main.js:424 does at every
site load. The venturi is SITE data, so every site_02 audit ever run — including
the numbers quoted at C in SPRINT10 — was of a corner block with no gap. The
SPRINT6 p1=7.4kN failure inverted: there the tool called a good site unriggable,
here it called a mean site cheap.
- sweep.js: setVenturi on both winds (the gap doesn't switch off for the settle);
both front-ends pass the site's funnel and print it, so a funnelled run is
legible as one.
- sweep.selftest.js (new, wired into b.test.js): the auditor gets an auditor.
Funnel must strictly raise every corner; a funnel-less site must be
byte-identical. Verified it fails when the setVenturi calls are deleted.
- rigging.js: setWorld(world) + session.setBudget(n)/setAnchors() — A's two asks.
Markers are rebuilt (the anchor set changes across sites) and disposed; stale
picks die with the old yard. Deletes A's "one private touch" into this module.
- dev_rigging.html: dead since SPRINT10 (called createWorld without a site, which
now throws) and nothing noticed, because a dev page has no selftest to go red.
Fixed, dressed, and given the site switch it should have had (N = next yard).
Verdict for C/A, in THREADS: site_02 PASSES with the funnel on — 64 of 66 lines
affordable, cheapest $20. The funnel kills nothing, so the gain does NOT need
dropping and E's tree stays put. It's a reach problem, not a gain problem: the
throat's radius is 5 m and the bed centre is 6.08 m away, so the gap screams over
the carport at +50% and reaches the garden at +0.0%.
selftest 300/0/0 (296 + 4 new).
Gate 2's actual deliverable. The node tool cannot dress, so it can only audit
the built-in snapshot or a resolved export and REFUSES A's dress-source site
JSON. This is the honest audit: audit.html builds the site the way the game does
— createWorld(await loadSite(name)) then dress() — and reads world.anchors, the
single source of DRESSED positions (GLB fascia + branch anchors, 8°-raked posts,
all of it), then runs the SAME sweep. It is the only way to audit a site with a
carport (site_02) before it ships.
tools/site_audit/audit.html?site=backyard_01
tools/site_audit/audit.html?site=site_02_corner_block&storm=storm_03_southerly
The winnability math now lives in ONE place, sweep.js, imported by both
front-ends — a tool built to catch reimplemented-formula drift doesn't get to
keep two copies of its own sweep. audit.mjs is refactored onto it (output
byte-identical); the node refusal message now hands you the exact audit.html URL.
Validated in-browser against backyard_01: dressed 12/12 anchors (GLBs loaded),
PASS, best line p1,p2,p3,p4 $65+$15 spare — identical to the node snapshot
verdict and to balance.test, off A's real data with no snapshot. That
cross-agreement also re-proves A's extraction is byte-identical.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A's gate-1 merge made createWorld REQUIRE a site (throws without one), which
crashed this tool's post cross-check: it called createWorld(scene, {wind}) with
no site. Fixed by reading the shipped data/sites/backyard_01.json and passing it
(loadSite fetch()es, so it can't run in node — read the file directly). The
cross-check is now BETTER: it verifies the dressed-snapshot posts against the
actual shipped site data, raked in createWorld, rather than against code.
Built-in audit green again; dress-source refusal (exit 2) and resolved-export
(exit 0) paths unchanged.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
A's committed site schema (SPRINT10 world.js loadSite/createWorld) is
dress-source, and my loadSite assumed resolved positions. Run head-on against
A's real data/sites/backyard_01.json the tool reported:
✗ FAIL — no quad in the band shades the bed at all. The site cannot be rigged.
That is a lie, and the dangerous kind: the site is fine; the TOOL couldn't read
it. It is the SPRINT6 unwinnable-site trap in reverse — a false negative that,
in a "every site runs the audit before it ships" workflow, condemns a good site.
Two things make the schema unreadable headless, both real:
· posts are pre-rake. JSON carries {id,x,z,h}; world.js:361 leans each post 8°
off centre. p4's spec (-3.2,-1.2) dresses to (-3.72,-1.40) — the exact 0.56 m
error this tool's own snapshot shipped in SPRINT9. Reading x/z raw re-makes it.
· house/tree anchors have no coordinates — only `node`, a GLB empty's name.
Their position exists only after dress() reads matrixWorld, and dress() needs
GLTFLoader + fetch, neither of which runs in node. Branch anchors are exactly
where the dangerous quads live (t2b at 10 kN), so dropping them silently is
the worst possible failure.
The correct source of dressed positions is createWorld(site).anchors, which is
browser-only. That path lands once A's data-driven createWorld is in main; until
then loadSite REFUSES dress-source JSON with the reason and the plan, and exits 2
(distinct from the winnability FAIL's exit 1). The built-in DRESSED snapshot and
a resolved { anchors:[{id,type,pos}] } export both still audit. Raised to A in
THREADS: audit in-browser off createWorld(site).anchors, or export resolved anchors.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
site_audit answers "is this site winnable?" before it ships — the check that
was missing when SPRINT6 shipped a yard whose bed-covering quad pulled 7.4 kN
against a shop that holds 6.5. It enumerates in-band quads, flies the real
storm headless, maps each corner to the cheapest tier that holds it, and
verdicts against the $80 budget. On backyard_01 it independently reproduces
THE LINE: p1,p2,p3,p4 at $65 + $15 spare, matching balance.test to within 2%.
It also caught three of my own bugs, which is the point of building it:
· it settled on STORM wind frozen at t=0 — the exact anti-pattern
balance.test documents at 1.94 kN vs 0.40 kN. Now settles on the calm
day on a running clock, the way main.js does.
· peakLoad is peak-since-ATTACH, so the settle transient was being
reported as a storm peak. sail.js gains resetPeaks().
· its p4 was typed from world.js's postSpecs, missing that posts are RAKED
8° away from centre — 0.56 m off. The audit now re-derives all four posts
from live world.js on every run and hard-fails on drift.
That last check is deliberately narrow. Node CANNOT dress: dress() needs
GLTFLoader (bare 'three') and fetch()es .glb over file://. createWorld() still
SUCCEEDS in node — it just returns the GRAYBOX yard, house at x=±5, no branch
anchors. So a headless tool that "reads world.js for the real yard" gets the
fictional x=±5 house that cost two sprints. Reading live code is not reading
truth. Verified in-browser: the dump matches the dressed yard on all 12
anchors. Posts are the only thing dress() never touches, so they're the only
thing worth cross-checking — and that check is what caught p4.
C IS RIGHT ABOUT p1 AND I WAS WRONG, for the third time. My comment claimed
C's 1.08 kN didn't reproduce, that p1 peaked at 1.27 and the line won on TIME
rather than headroom. Re-measured on the dressed yard, same flight:
shade cloth p1 0.98 kN 0/4 lost membrane p1 1.23 kN p1 LETS GO
p1 never touches its 1.2 kN rating on cloth — 18% of real headroom. Where 1.27
came from: a loadout where a corner BROKE and dumped its share onto p1 (the
same quad with hardware the budget can't buy reads 2.48). Any p1 number
gathered without checking `lost` measures a cascade, not a fabric.
So the fabric is the decision, not a skin: 0.98 vs 1.23 against a 1.20 rating
is the difference between the $5 carabiner holding the wild night and failing
it. New assert `fabric decides p1` locks that in, so nobody has to trust the
paragraph.
selftest.html rendered ['A'..'E'] while importing BAL too, so the balance
suite ran, counted toward the summary, and had every row silently dropped —
including, had one gone red, the row saying which assert failed. The merge
gate was invisible in its own report. My bug: I added the import, not the
renderer. Now derived from the report.
Selftest: 276 passed, 0 failed, 0 skipped (LANE BAL now visible).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
