Lane D S18: [D] THE KNIFE — the verb, the four unwired seams, and the week re-flown honestly
The knife as shipped (hold X at a cleat, the trade printed, its own section on the invoice), the hold-E prompt that has never once been drawn in five sprints, the ruling that a cut is not a break on any surface that reads a corner, four seams this sprint published and nobody wired, seven nights re-flown on the fabric the game actually flies now, and the two branches of night 5 measured side by side: +$142 with the knife against −$83 without it, on 1.2 seconds of held key. Two things filed for John rather than tuned by me: the knife has no PRICE on the shipped emergency (the cut costs 1 HP of garden, because the hail is over before you arrive and pay.garden is 0), and declining is free again at ★0.0 because the clamp eats it. Both are rulings where two correct decisions meet. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
parent
60771875d6
commit
097f453b9d
323
THREADS.md
323
THREADS.md
@ -10976,3 +10976,326 @@ anchors are your GLB), but the tooling is now waiting, not TODO.
|
||||
**Next: D's second pass** — the knife (B's `cutAway` is live, tallied and printing on the
|
||||
invoice; A authored the shipped emergency FOR it, the cowboy tied to the $180 carport
|
||||
beam), then the re-flown week. Gate 6 is John's.
|
||||
|
||||
[D] 2026-07-25 — 🔪 **GATE 1.3 LANDED: THE KNIFE — hold X at a cleat, the trade printed on the
|
||||
glass, and the ruling that stops it being a trap. Plus FOUR SEAMS THIS SPRINT PUBLISHED AND
|
||||
NEVER WIRED, all four found by playing the night rather than by a green suite.**
|
||||
Selftest **584/0/0** (574 baseline + 10, all in d.test.js).
|
||||
|
||||
── **1 · THE KNIFE AS SHIPPED** ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
|
||||
**INPUT — hold X for 1.2 s, standing at a cleat.** One verb, the WHOLE sail (B's `cutAway()`
|
||||
with no argument), because that is what DESIGN.md line 165 means. The per-corner cut B also
|
||||
exposed is not this verb: DESIGN.md lists the **quick-release corner** ("installed in prep") as
|
||||
its own tool, and depowering one corner is that tool's job. One sprint, one verb.
|
||||
|
||||
· **X, not a third hold-E target.** At a post base E already offers two things and
|
||||
`interact.nearest()` picks by DISTANCE, so a knife registered at the same position would race
|
||||
the repair for the same key — and the one input a player must never misfire is the
|
||||
irreversible one.
|
||||
· **A HOLD, not a press.** This is the most irreversible input in the game; a tap that spends
|
||||
the sail is a button. It dies the three ways a hold-E dies: let go, walk off the cleat, get
|
||||
put down by a gust (measured: `knockdown` mid-cut zeroes the progress and the knife does NOT
|
||||
stomp the knocked state).
|
||||
· ⚖️ **IT DOES NOT WRITE `player.busy`, and that is deliberate.** interact.js's header states
|
||||
the invariant — that module both enters and leaves `busy`, "so a dropped release cannot
|
||||
strand the player". A second writer is how a player gets locked in a state nothing releases.
|
||||
So the knife refuses to START while busy (no cutting mid-crank, mid-poke) and cancels itself
|
||||
if a locked state arrives. The cost is that there is no cut animation: **filed, not faked.**
|
||||
· ⚖️ **WHERE YOU CAN CUT: at the cleat, never at the bracket** — and this is the mechanic, not
|
||||
a limitation. ladder.js's own header states the yard's rule ("a sail post is tensioned from a
|
||||
cleat at its base, a tree anchor is a strop you throw") while a bracket is worked at height.
|
||||
**The corner about to take the $180 carport is CB1, a bracket at y=2.36 that needs a ladder
|
||||
you have no time to fetch.** So you cannot reach the corner that is failing — you cut the
|
||||
sail at one you CAN reach and the whole thing goes limp. The ladder is for repairs (slow, two
|
||||
trips, both hands); the knife is for the seconds you actually have. Complements, not rivals.
|
||||
· ⚖️ **HANDS ARE NOT A GATE.** A knife is on your belt and cutting one line is one-handed — but
|
||||
the real reason is that gating the signature decision behind dropping the spare would put an
|
||||
undiscoverable inventory step inside a 5.9-second window, and a player reads that as the game
|
||||
refusing rather than as a choice.
|
||||
|
||||
**THE HUD READ — and building it found something five sprints old (see §2).** The panel prints
|
||||
the trade, both halves, always, because "cut or ride it out" is unanswerable off one of them:
|
||||
|
||||
[X] CUT THE SAIL LOOSE — hold
|
||||
saves $205 at risk · garden gnome, the carport
|
||||
costs the garden — 100% now, bare for 59s
|
||||
|
||||
"$N at risk" is **the board's own vocabulary**, deliberately: that morning's offer card priced
|
||||
this night at "$205 at risk", and the knife is the one move that takes that number off the
|
||||
table. Same words, two cards apart. And the saves side is priced through **main.js's own
|
||||
collateral walk, injected** (`collateralWalk`, extracted pure for this) — one walk, two readers,
|
||||
so the panel cannot advertise a saving the invoice will not honour. The refusal names the real
|
||||
reason and there are two of them (a cleat to walk to, versus every live corner up a wall);
|
||||
the first version was one constant that always blamed the bracket, and on the swing lawn it
|
||||
told me to fetch a ladder for a corner that does not exist. `needsLadder`'s own SPRINT10 disease
|
||||
on the surface that exists to explain it — caught by playing.
|
||||
|
||||
**THE PAPERWORK.** A's invoice line was already waiting. What it needed:
|
||||
· **its own section, on ANY night.** The cut rows shipped INSIDE `w?.emergency`, so a sail cut
|
||||
loose on an ordinary Tuesday printed nothing. Principle 2 has no "callouts only" clause.
|
||||
Now: `THE KNIFE — sail cut loose at CB1, Q1, Q3 — 32s in, deliberate · for the carport ·
|
||||
your call`, and B's `reason` field finally carries something (the most expensive thing those
|
||||
corners were holding up, which is the sentence a player would say out loud).
|
||||
· **a subtitle** — a cut sail headlined "Every corner held." would put three accounts of one
|
||||
night on one card, one of them false.
|
||||
· **a verdict.** With `lost` empty and hp under the line, `verdictFor` reached mode `uncovered`
|
||||
and told a player who had just cut the sail down that *"the hail fell where your sail
|
||||
wasn't"*. That is the worst sentence the card could say: it blames placement for a decision.
|
||||
Two new modes, and they fire ONLY when nothing of yours failed — if a corner blew as well
|
||||
that failure is the louder fact and the existing modes keep speaking truthfully.
|
||||
|
||||
── **2 · ⚠️ THE HOLD-E PROMPT HAS NEVER BEEN DRAWN. FIVE SPRINTS.** ────────────────────────
|
||||
`interact.step()` returns `{target, progress, label, holding, usable}` "for hud.js to draw the
|
||||
prompt + radial" — its own words, my file. **main.js throws the return value away, hud.js has
|
||||
no prompt element, and the only renderer of a prompt in this repo is `dev_player.html`, a
|
||||
bench.** So every sentence this lane has written for the player's hands — *"out of reach —
|
||||
needs the ladder"*, *"push the water off (169 kg)"*, *"hands full"*, and the entire greyed-
|
||||
prompt surface I built for Lane A in SPRINT13 — has never reached a player. You walk to a
|
||||
broken corner, hold a key a help line mentioned, and the game says nothing until dawn.
|
||||
|
||||
**Same disease as `setFabric` and the F key before it: the code was right, the wire was
|
||||
missing, and no assert could see it because the gap was on the glass.** It is now
|
||||
`createVerbPanel` (knife.js, D's own overlay — hud.js is A's file and its header already
|
||||
assigns "the repair prompt, which Lane D already owns" to this lane; z-index 9, so a card
|
||||
always wins). It lives in knife.js and not player.js for one reason and it is the suite:
|
||||
player.js statically imports GLTFLoader, which is why d.test.js has never imported it. **A
|
||||
prompt surface only a browser can construct is a prompt surface with no asserts.** Now pinned.
|
||||
|
||||
Verified by play, first time on the glass: `[E] take the broom` → `[E] put the broom back` →
|
||||
`[E] push the water off (165 kg)` → poke → 165 kg becomes 34 and the player STAGGERS, with
|
||||
q1 dropping 2.63 kN → 0.69 kN. Sprint 5's joke, finally legible.
|
||||
|
||||
── **3 · ⚖️ THE MONEY: A CORNER YOU CUT IS NOT A CORNER THAT FAILED** ──────────────────────
|
||||
B ruled it on the rig ("a cut is a DECISION… warranty must never chase a corner the player
|
||||
chose to let go") and emitted no `break`. But `_releaseCorner` sets `c.broken` for a cut exactly
|
||||
as for an overload, and **every ledger surface reads `broken`.** So on the tree as merged,
|
||||
taking DESIGN.md's signature decision billed you for it on five surfaces at once:
|
||||
|
||||
the cut corner's hardware went on `bill` · the collateral walk BILLED AND WRECKED the $180
|
||||
carport you cut the sail to save · a four-corner cut tripped the gnome's two-corner rule ·
|
||||
`clean` was voided by the collateral it caused · week.js booked a free warranty callout
|
||||
tomorrow for every corner you let go, and docked standing for each one.
|
||||
|
||||
The invoice would have printed *"You spent the sail to keep the steel. That is the trade the
|
||||
knife is for"* directly above a $180 charge for the thing you kept. Nobody wrote a wrong line:
|
||||
A built both halves, B built the physics, and **the join is a flag on an object that no verb
|
||||
set until now.**
|
||||
|
||||
⚖️ **THE RULING, B's extended to every surface that reads a corner: a cut bills nothing, wrecks
|
||||
nothing, books no warranty and costs no standing. Its price is the garden — and through the
|
||||
garden the night's fee — and that is enough.** `answerableFor` gains `cut` and drops it from
|
||||
`yours`; `rigRecordFor` gains `cut`; week.js's warranty and rep blocks skip it exactly where
|
||||
they already skip `theirs`. `lost` still counts it (the sail IS on the lawn; the corners-intact
|
||||
read stays honest) and the refund now counts it too — **"lose the sail, save the anchors" is a
|
||||
ledger line, not a slogan**, and `!c.broken` alone was quietly taking your steel as well.
|
||||
|
||||
── **4 · 🚨 FOUR SEAMS PUBLISHED THIS SPRINT AND NEVER WIRED.** ────────────────────────────
|
||||
Every one is data or a name in A's files, every one was B's to rule and A's to apply, every one
|
||||
was pre-authorised in writing ("revert-and-tell-me applies… yours is canon the moment it
|
||||
lands"), and **not one of them was visible to 574 green asserts.** I found all four by playing
|
||||
night 5 and reading the cards.
|
||||
|
||||
1. ⚖️ **B's AUTHORED COWBOY RIG had not landed.** The dispatch read *"CB1 carabiner — ON THE
|
||||
GROUND"*: A's flagged placeholder. That is a different night from the one this sprint is
|
||||
about — with the carport corner arriving down, the $180 is `theirs`, unbillable and
|
||||
unwreckable, and **DESIGN.md line 165's signature decision has no object.** B's set adopted
|
||||
verbatim: `q3 shackle · q1 carabiner · tr1b carabiner BROKEN · cb1 SHACKLE on the 0.22 beam`.
|
||||
2. ⚖️ **`pay: { garden: 0 }` had not landed** — B's ruling that the garden BONUS is off on a
|
||||
callout. The first emergency invoice I rendered paid **+$38** for a bed nobody had a prep
|
||||
phase to protect.
|
||||
3. ⚠️ **`rig.breakCorner?.()` — THE DOOR IS CALLED `failCorner`.** Measured live:
|
||||
`typeof rig.failCorner === 'function'`, `typeof rig.breakCorner === 'undefined'`. **An
|
||||
optional call to a renamed method is a silent no-op that reads exactly like a call** — D's
|
||||
own `rigging.setWorld` lesson, quoted in that very file, arriving through the pattern built
|
||||
to prevent it. So no corner arrived down and every card that said "ON THE GROUND" was wrong.
|
||||
A's fallback reasoning covered it ("a $5 carabiner on the beam fails in seconds anyway") and
|
||||
**that is exactly what hid it** — under B's canon rig the arrived-broken corner is a
|
||||
carabiner on a 0.88 branch that does not self-destruct.
|
||||
4. ⚠️ **`attach(…, {at, wind})` was never passed, so the cloth flew the wrong storm.** C found
|
||||
it, B fixed it, nobody wired it: measured on the shipped emergency, **`rig.clockSkew` read
|
||||
30.02** while the sky, garden, debris and player were all thirty seconds in. B's own number
|
||||
for what that hides: the same rig pulls **90 N at t=0 and 655 N at t=40**. The knife's own
|
||||
invoice line said *"cut loose 9s in"* on a night you arrive at 30, because the log stamps
|
||||
the SAIL's clock — one bug, two symptoms. Wired by asking the night (`week.job.emergency`),
|
||||
not by a flag: with a `wind` B's attach genuinely PRE-FLIES the thirty seconds.
|
||||
**Pinned so it cannot come back:** every door main.js feature-detects on the emergency path is
|
||||
asserted to EXIST (`failCorner`/`cutAway`/`seedClock`/`setFabric`, plus `attach`'s `{at}`),
|
||||
because a feature-detect is only safe if something checks the feature.
|
||||
|
||||
── **5 · THE RE-FLOWN WEEK — first honest measurement of this game** ───────────────────────
|
||||
Real path: splash → board → click an offer → sheet/dispatch → rig → ENTER → storm at
|
||||
`SHADES.step(1/60)` → invoice, seven nights. Disclosed harness: picks go through
|
||||
`session.rig()/cycleHardware()` (the exact calls the click handler makes) because RMB-orbit is
|
||||
a pointer-capture drag the pane cannot do; **every board click, F, ENTER, WASD, E and X was a
|
||||
real event.** Post-fabric-fix, shade cloth throughout except N7.
|
||||
|
||||
· **N1 — TOOK THE BOOKED JOB (the change from S17, and the ruling caused it).** The pool yard
|
||||
was $57 against the Hendersons' $42 and I took it cold in S17 for free. With **"−½★
|
||||
standing" printed on the card**, +$15 for +$45 exposure and a rep multiplier that prices the
|
||||
whole week read like a bad trade on night one. Rigged the post quad in **carabiners ($20)
|
||||
off the brief's own words ("Nothing tonight will test it")** — and **P5 BLEW ANYWAY**, on the
|
||||
calmest night in the game. Garden 98, +$94, ★3.0→2.5.
|
||||
· **N2 — spine, southerly × backyard.** Post quad, shackles, +spare. 4/4, garden 91, +$75.
|
||||
**The fabric fix's first visible consequence: the shade cloth LEAKS** — "6 HP of hail reached
|
||||
the bed", and B's SPRINT16 sentence *"The membrane stops every stone"* fires for the first
|
||||
time in a played game. Pre-fix the sim always flew the membrane, so that note was unreachable.
|
||||
· **N3 — spine, earlybuster × corner block. Flew FOUR CARABINERS ($20)** — a harness slip on my
|
||||
side that I am reporting rather than hiding, and it is the week's most uncomfortable number:
|
||||
**q1 blew, three held, garden 86, +$104, the best night of the week.** The cheapest rig in
|
||||
the shop on the $205-exposure yard, because the quad never touches the carport. The trap you
|
||||
do not tie to cannot bite.
|
||||
· **N4 — TOOK THE BOOKED SWING LAWN: site_03's FIRST COLD PLAY EVER** (S17's N4 took the capped
|
||||
repeat, so nobody has ever played this yard). Quad t1/t2/p1/s1_f1, **rated shackle on the
|
||||
swing frame** (2925 N effective) because the yard tells you it is the weak link. **The rated
|
||||
shackle went FIRST at t≈45 and took t1 and t2 with it.** Garden 91, and: garden gnome −$25,
|
||||
**the swing set −$140**, clean bonus struck through, **−$148, ★2.5→0.0.** The biggest single
|
||||
loss I have measured. 📇 **Filed for E/A:** the yard's anchor spread forces a big sail (my
|
||||
quad was **80 m²** against 35–42 m² on the other yards) and the only 4th corner near the bed
|
||||
is the swing frame at 0.45 with $140 under it. The best steel in the shop is not enough at
|
||||
80 m². And ⚠️ **the pyrrhic verdict is too warm here**: "THE GARDEN MADE IT… That is what the
|
||||
sail was for" over −$148, a wrecked swing set and ★0.0 reads as congratulations. Collateral,
|
||||
not corner count, should be able to cool that sentence.
|
||||
· **N5 — TOOK THE EMERGENCY. The mandated decline and the mandated callout are the same
|
||||
choice, exactly as A designed.** See §6.
|
||||
· **N6 — spine, the icenight.** **THE GRUDGE LANDED**: the board card said *"They remember
|
||||
night 5 — you took another job"* and the job sheet *"They have not forgotten night 5. You
|
||||
are here on their second-choice terms."* Post quad in shackles; **p5 blew again, this time
|
||||
with a SHACKLE** (3200 N). Garden 16, +$12. ⚠️ **S17 measured this night at −$83**; the whole
|
||||
difference is the warranty chain, not the ice — my N5 was a cut, and a cut books no warranty.
|
||||
· **N7 — spine, the soaker, membrane (F), and the broom.** $75 ring rated-on-q1 on the audit's
|
||||
cheapest-holding quad (q1/tr1/tr1b/q3). Broomed a **165 kg** belly at t=43 → 34 kg, staggered,
|
||||
and q1 fell 2.63 → 0.69 kN: **4/4 held.** And then **garden 49% — ONE POINT under the win
|
||||
line**, fee docked to 35%, +$4. *"THE GARDEN IS GONE — and every corner held. The hail fell
|
||||
where your sail wasn't."* ⚠️ **The audit's cheapest-HOLDING quad misses the bed by enough to
|
||||
lose the night**, which is the coverage-vs-holding trade stated as a number: I saved the rig
|
||||
and lost the job by 1 HP. S17 flew a quad including q2 and got garden 96.
|
||||
|
||||
**THE WEEK:** 7/7 nights · **5/7 gardens** · **$327** · ★0.5 · 6 warranty jobs ·
|
||||
*"You made the least wrong call seven times running."*
|
||||
S17 read 7/7 · 6/7 · $401 · ★0.0 · 5 warranty jobs. Different choices on three mornings, so
|
||||
this is not a controlled comparison and I am not presenting it as one.
|
||||
|
||||
── **6 · NIGHT 5, BOTH BRANCHES OF ONE MORNING — the number the sprint asked for** ─────────
|
||||
Same seek (`week.advance()`×4 — A's disclosed move; bank $80, ★3.0, so it is comparable to A's
|
||||
retracted run), same dispatch, same arrival at t=30. One decision.
|
||||
|
||||
| | corners at dawn | garden | fee | garden bonus | clean | collateral | **AMOUNT DUE** | standing |
|
||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| **CUT at t=32.3** | 0/4 (3 cut, 1 arrived down) | 84% | +$114 | **$0** | +$20 | none | **+$142** | ★3.0 → 3.0 |
|
||||
| **RIDE IT OUT** | 1/4 (cb1+q1 blew) | 85% | +$114 | $0 | $0 void | **−$205** | **−$83** | ★3.0 → **0.0** |
|
||||
|
||||
**A $225 swing on 1.2 seconds of held key.** Ran to q3's cleat in 1.1 s, held X from t=31.1,
|
||||
the cut landed at **32.3**, and riding it out puts **cb1 and q1 down between t=35 and t=36** —
|
||||
B's 35.9 confirmed in the shipped game, so **the window from arrival is 5.9 s and I used 2.3 of
|
||||
it.** (At the honest night-5 bank from the cold play, $205, riding it out leaves $122 and ★0.0:
|
||||
crippling, not a game over. The $0 above is the seek's $80 bank, not a balance claim.)
|
||||
|
||||
⚠️ **AND HERE IS THE PROBLEM, WHICH I AM REPORTING AND NOT TUNING: THE KNIFE'S STATED PRICE IS
|
||||
NOT CHARGED ON THIS NIGHT.** The cut cost **1 HP of garden** — 84% cut versus 85% ridden —
|
||||
because the southerly's hail is 2 s of pea stones that are over before you arrive, and the
|
||||
remaining 58 s is wind and 5 mm/hr of rain the bed barely notices. B's ruling that "the garden
|
||||
is the STAKE, not the wage" is right in principle, and with `pay.garden = 0` the garden only
|
||||
reaches the money through `win = hp >= 50` — which 84% is nowhere near. **So on the shipped
|
||||
emergency the knife is a $225 free win with no trade-off, and a player who knows it takes it
|
||||
every time.** The two rulings are in tension and it needs one person to hold both:
|
||||
· B's `pay.garden = 0` is what removes the knife's price (correct for the callout, fatal for
|
||||
the trade).
|
||||
· the storm cannot be re-authored — it is night 2's, and that is the one-variable law.
|
||||
· `arriveAt` is ROADMAP's own number.
|
||||
⚖️ **Not mine to re-rule at the end of a sprint. Gate 6, John's, with the numbers above.** The
|
||||
shape of the decision is right and it is the best thirty seconds in this game; the PRICE is
|
||||
missing, and it is missing because two correct rulings meet on one night.
|
||||
|
||||
── **7 · ⚠️ JOHN'S RULING HAS A FLOOR HOLE, and it costs nothing at exactly the wrong moment** ──
|
||||
Measured in the cold play: I reached night 5 at **★0.0**, and standing a client up at ★0.0
|
||||
**costs nothing** — `settle()` clamps at `REP.MIN`, the fee multiplier is already ×0.88, and
|
||||
there is nothing left to dock. **A fee-maximiser who has bled out can dodge every booked night
|
||||
for free again, which is precisely the player the ruling was written for.**
|
||||
|
||||
Both papers were also lying about it: the offer card promised "−½★ standing" the game would not
|
||||
charge, and the invoice printed *"stood up the Hendersons · −½★ standing"* four rows above
|
||||
*"reputation ★ 0.0 → ★ 0.0"* — **the invoice arguing with itself, on John's own ruling.** I
|
||||
fixed the PAPER half only (`standUpCost` clamps against the standing the charge lands on; at
|
||||
the floor both surfaces say **"nothing left to dock"**, and the invoice adds *"Your standing is
|
||||
already on the floor, so this one was free. They will remember the phone call anyway."*).
|
||||
⚖️ **Whether the ruling should have teeth at the floor is John's, not mine** — the candidates
|
||||
are a money component, letting rep go negative, or accepting that the floor is the floor. Until
|
||||
he rules, the documents tell the truth about the number. **And the thing I actually felt was
|
||||
not the star: it was night 6's board saying "They remember night 5 — you took another job."
|
||||
Clause 3 is carrying the ruling at ★0.0, on its own.**
|
||||
|
||||
── **8 · WHICH OF MY OWN S17 NUMBERS NO LONGER HOLD** ─────────────────────────────────────
|
||||
· ❌ **"the audit's own $40 clean line broke at tr1b 1.17/1.2" — WITHDRAWN as filed.** B is
|
||||
right and their re-ruling is better than my filing: the boundary was never the defect. tr1b's
|
||||
hint is 0.88, so a $5 carabiner there holds **1.056 kN, not 1.2**, and it broke at 1.168 —
|
||||
10.6% over its REAL ceiling. I reasoned from the price list instead of the yard. And the
|
||||
information was already on the panel: `summary.weakest` reads **tr1b** before you commit.
|
||||
**B's diagnosis stands: $40 is a total, not a line.** My own N3 this week flew four
|
||||
carabiners at $20 and lost only q1 — the corner with the worst load-to-rating ratio.
|
||||
· ❌ **"the wildnight's pinned recipe loses p2 then p3 in the played game" — RESOLVED, and it
|
||||
was a real bug, not a harness artefact.** B found the variable: `setFabric` never reached the
|
||||
sim, so my play flew the membrane while every card said cloth. My decimals (3.48 / 3.90) were
|
||||
the membrane's. Vindicated and void in the same breath.
|
||||
· ❌ **"+$401 / 6-of-7 gardens / the $80 clean-win line" — all measured on a fabric the game
|
||||
never flew.** This week reads $327 and 5/7 on different choices; nothing above should be
|
||||
treated as a target until somebody re-flies a controlled week.
|
||||
· ❌ **"N7 garden 96 FULL, +$28"** — I flew a different quad. Same yard, same storm, same
|
||||
hardware budget, same fabric: **49%.** Coverage, not steel.
|
||||
· ✅ **"declining costs nothing, so the board is a free option"** — answered by John, and the
|
||||
answer works everywhere except the floor (§7).
|
||||
· ✅ **the two-Vasilaros morning** (N7 offers the same client the same yard twice under "the
|
||||
other goes to somebody else") is still there. Still cosmetic, still filed with a smile.
|
||||
|
||||
── **9 · DOES DECLINING COST ENOUGH TO HURT, AND LITTLE ENOUGH TO BE WORTH IT SOMETIMES?** ──
|
||||
**Yes in the middle of the ladder, and no at the bottom.** −½★ is priced exactly right where it
|
||||
bites: it is a real 2% fee cut compounding over the week plus the warranty exposure that comes
|
||||
with a night you did not rig, and on night 1 it flipped my choice away from a job I took
|
||||
without thinking in S17. That is the ruling working — it made a marginal morning into a
|
||||
decision. And it is little enough to be worth paying: **+$142 against −$83 made night 5 an
|
||||
obvious yes even with the star on the line**, which is right, because that is what a $205
|
||||
emergency at double rates SHOULD look like.
|
||||
Where it fails is ★0.0, and it fails completely (§7). One sentence for gate 6: **the price of
|
||||
saying no should not be the only currency a broke player has already spent.**
|
||||
|
||||
── **10 · DOES THE KNIFE FEEL LIKE A DECISION OR A BUTTON?** ──────────────────────────────
|
||||
**A decision, and the best thirty seconds in the game — with one caveat that is not about the
|
||||
input.** What makes it a decision rather than a button, in the order I felt them:
|
||||
1. **You have to get there.** The carport corner is up a wall; the cleat is 2.8 m the other
|
||||
way; and the clock is running in weather that shoves you. The verb has a WALK in it.
|
||||
2. **The trade is printed before you commit**, both halves, in the board's own words, and the
|
||||
two numbers are genuinely incommensurable ($205 of somebody's property against a bed you
|
||||
were called out to save). I hesitated with my hand on the key, which is the test.
|
||||
3. **It is a hold**, so the decision has a length, and a gust can take it off you.
|
||||
4. **The paperwork admits it.** THE KNIFE on the invoice, in the verdict, in the subtitle —
|
||||
nowhere does the card pretend the sail came down by itself.
|
||||
⚠️ **The caveat: the TELL is knowledge, not a gauge.** CB1's bar reads 63% of its effective
|
||||
704 N at t=35 and the corner is gone at 35.9 — **the amber band lasts about one second.** So a
|
||||
first-time player cannot react to the HUD; they react to the DISPATCH having told them cb1 is a
|
||||
shackle on a carport beam. That is defensible (DESIGN.md: "half the puzzle is finding what's
|
||||
about to fail") and it is worth stating out loud, because it means the emergency teaches by
|
||||
reading the card, not by watching the bar. 📇 **Filed, one idea, not a request:** the corner bar
|
||||
could carry rate-of-change on a bracket corner — the one place a second of amber is not enough.
|
||||
And the honest remaining gap: **there is no cut ANIMATION**, because the knife refuses to write
|
||||
`busy`. The radial carries it; a `Crank`-family clip driven without touching the busy state is
|
||||
the fix and it needs interact.js's handshake widened rather than bypassed. Filed for S19.
|
||||
|
||||
── **FILED, in priority order** ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
|
||||
1. ⚖️ **John / gate 6: the knife has no price on the shipped emergency** (§6) and **declining
|
||||
is free at ★0.0** (§7). Both are rulings, both have their numbers above, neither is a bug.
|
||||
2. 📇 **A:** three of my edits are in your files and every one is `revert on sight` if you
|
||||
disagree — the `answerableFor`/`rigRecordFor` cut split, `collateralWalk` extracted pure
|
||||
(the knife's read is injected with it), the two `verdictFor` modes, the subtitle branch, the
|
||||
refund predicate, THE KNIFE section in hud.js, and the clamped stand-up wording. The
|
||||
settlement drops `booked`, which is why the invoice says *"nobody was expecting you"* on a
|
||||
night you took the booked job — **that line is false as it stands** and the fix needs one
|
||||
field carried onto the settlement, which is yours.
|
||||
3. 📇 **E/A: site_03 forces an 80 m² sail** and the best steel in the shop fails there (§N4).
|
||||
4. 📇 **B:** `attach({at, wind})` pre-flies all four corners and `failCorner` runs after, so the
|
||||
arrived-down corner is not down during those 30 s — you offered to take the broken set into
|
||||
`attach` and it is now worth it: on the canon rig, `tr1b` being up for the pre-fly is load
|
||||
the other three did not have to carry. Small, but it is the night's opening state.
|
||||
5. 📇 **Integrator: hud.js's ticker does not refresh under stepped fast-forward** (it is called
|
||||
from `frame()`, not `step()`), so `pushEvent` lines are invisible in every stepped playtest —
|
||||
including "sail cut loose". The verb panel updates inside `player.update` and does not have
|
||||
this problem. Not a shipped bug; it is a harness blind spot, and it hid the knife's ticker
|
||||
line from me for an hour.
|
||||
|
||||
Loading…
Reference in New Issue
Block a user